“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Codenames 20
|
Minor point of order: By the standard rulebook, a hyphenated compound word doesn't qualify as a single-word clue. But since nobody objected, probably best to just let it stand.
(October 19th, 2017, 09:17)T-hawk Wrote: Minor point of order: By the standard rulebook, a hyphenated compound word doesn't qualify as a single-word clue. But since nobody objected, probably best to just let it stand. I PM’d David Corperial and Pindicator to see if they were fine with it, and there were no complaints. I am sorry though, I think I missed that rule when searching to see if it was legal or not.
Surprise! Turns out I'm a girl!
That's cool, the rules allow a lot of leeway in terms of house rules, and more importantly specify that the final arbiter if there's any uncertainty is the opposing spymaster. So you definitely did the right thing.
I don't think the spirit of the rules is broken by hyphenated words, so long as they're aiming to get across a single concept and are a common phrasing - see also the rules for acronyms. Hyphenated words are probably banned by default because it's easier to do that than to makie it clear in the rules exactly which would be allowed and which wouldn't.
At first glance, my top 6 choices were MERCURY, ANTARCTICA, LASER, PLOT, RAY, and MISSILE. I missed SCREEN, which are ubiquitous in scifi: another strong choice. I don't like PRINCESS/SOLDIER, and like Lewwyn says, I think we should avoid words that are better associated with another genre, or refer mainly to specific franchises. The clue wasn't Skywalker or Spy, after all. My personal preference would be SCREEN -> MERCURY -> PLOT next, but I'm happy with MERCURY -> PLOT -> SCREEN if that's the team consensus.
I don't think the order of the next three matters too much: with this size of clue we're likely to be expecting some grey speedbumps anyway, and we'll guess all of these answers in time.
I'm not convinced by the argument that we should avoid references to specific franchises: any Star Wars clue would immediately lose other sci-fi references we might be meant to get (Mercury, in this case). Anyway, if we do get the next three right, I'm happy guessing something generic (Missile?) for our final word. |