Posts: 1,267
Threads: 7
Joined: Apr 2006
I reckon I'll go for the sixth spot, provided you don't mind playing vanilla with no DLC civs.
I tried out a Medieval start. It is full of weird and wonderful and mostly undocumented stuff. I started with two settlers, a scout and an archer. When the first settler founded a city it had several population and a spearman and a builder appeared from nowhere. The second city also had a free builder and population but no military unit. After that, things were closer to normality.
As far as research goes, all techs and civics below the medieval age were researched, all techs and civics in the early medieval column were boosted... except one civic. And there was a civic from earlier that was both completed and boosted, resulting in some odd graphics.
So overall I'm neutral on the idea of a medieval start. On one hand I'm concerned about balance and whether a medieval start game will suffer from the late game economy problems that have been surfacing in other PBEMs but even sooner. On the other hand it's an interesting new thing to try that's off the beaten path of previous games.
I might look at a classical start at some point to see what you get for free there.