WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Serdoa]

So, wait, you found my self-vote fishy, but you still parked on pindicator? 

naufragar

Yup, because when I voted, Commodore was on you for the self-vote and I didn't feel like doubling up on that. Rowain asked me about changing my vote after Lewwyn explained you as Serdoa being Serdoa.

That really doesn't explain it though. You said you found it fishy. Yet, not fishy enough to at least test the waters about it? At the start of the game when there is nothing else to go on? And then you accuse Lewwyn because he votes me, but fails to mention the self-vote, but you don't vote him either - and now you say that his explanation is the reason you did not change your vote to me, but still stay on pindicator? But why would you trust Lewwyn about that? Especially after you called us both out. 

I get the feeling that you know very well who is a wolf and who not. It's hard to argue with someone when you know your arguments and explanations are lies, isn't it?

[Commodore]

I'll join you on GeneralKillCavalry, seems very eager to just hop all over the place.

Naufragar is nervous, twitchy, talkative...so about exactly how I'd expect nau to be in his very first WW.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

Glad you look back on our earlier games as well as I do, Rowain

Lot of energy from GKC and naufrager early - both changing their votes quickly without waiting for everyone to chime in.    No wait, now I'm wrong.  Naufrager didn't change his vote but has just mentioned people.  GKC has swapped his vote twice now.

I'd like to see some GeneralKilCavalry pushed up as well I think.  3 votes in 4 posts, minimal typing.

Do you want me to make that into 4 votes in 6 posts? Not a lot to discuss at this stage, except Serdoa/naufragar being a bit confrontational and awkward.

[BRickAstley]

3 minutes ago (This post was last modified: Less than 1 minute ago by GeneralKilCavalry.)

Just wanted to officially call it out, as it says in the rules, Editing posts is not allowed. But this is your first game and first post GKC, so no punishment is warranted. Just, don't make it a habit of forgetting.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

3 minutes ago (This post was last modified: Less than 1 minute ago by GeneralKilCavalry.)

Just wanted to officially call it out, as it says in the rules, Editing posts is not allowed. But this is your first game and first post GKC, so no punishment is warranted. Just, don't make it a habit of forgetting.

I made sure to re-read the rules again, and I'll not edit posts. Again, just a color change, but I am now well aware of the rules.

[Chevalier Mal Fet]

Oh, it's been open for an hour and there's 6 pages of posts.

This might be a lot more work than I anticipated. x_x If I don't respond to things right away, it's going to be because I have a job and there's a lot of text to wade through.

-starts wading-

[pindicator]

Who are all our first-time players?

[Gaspar]

I agree that naufs post was super scummy by being so defensive so early. However I also think that jumping all over him reeks of a bus. So I'm going to keep my vote right where it is.

I mean what's more likely - nauf is a clumsy wolf or a confused villager? I feel like Rowain and Serdoa would know this too.

[naufragar]

That really doesn't explain it though. You said you found it fishy. Yet, not fishy enough to at least test the waters about it? At the start of the game when there is nothing else to go on? And then you accuse Lewwyn because he votes me, but fails to mention the self-vote, but you don't vote him either - and now you say that his explanation is the reason you did not change your vote to me, but still stay on pindicator? But why would you trust Lewwyn about that? Especially after you called us both out. 

I get the feeling that you know very well who is a wolf and who not. It's hard to argue with someone when you know your arguments and explanations are lies, isn't it?

But I did test the waters about it. Lewwyn asked when the love fest would end, and here I poke him on his vote. I draw attention to what I think is a slight weirdness (which coincidentally draws attention to your self vote).

I have not accused Lewwyn unless you've got a much lower threshold for accusation than I do. "and now you say that his explanation is the reason you did not change your vote to me" You've made an error here. I wasn't voting for you. Lewwyn explained why he didn't mention your self vote. This doesn't change me off you, because I already wasn't on you. I didn't hop on you because nothing had changed. The only new piece of info I got (info in scare quotes, so be it) was that the self vote wasn't unusual. As for Lewwyn, you can't be mad at me for accusing him while also being mad at me for not voting for him. I pointed out something that pricked my ears; he provided an answer. I'm not throwing my vote at someone every time I want to question them.

Notice I'm still not throwing my vote at you. This is because after Commodore's first mention, no one has reacted negatively to your vote and one person even attempted to be exculpatory.

[naufragar]

Super cross-post. Expect a lot of that.

Who are all our first-time players?

My first time playing forum werewolf, but I've played 3 or 4 board game sessions of One Night Ultimate Werewolf.