WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[El Grillo]

@pindicator: This is my first time playing on this site, but I've played a few games back on teamliquid.net (albeit with a very different game style).

@Gaspar: We're not playing with majority hammer rules, so if you agree that his behavior is scummy, there's no reason not to vote him for now while we wait for everyone to get involved. Or start another wagon on whoever else you want to get some feedback on. Is that still Rowain for you? With fixed-length days, it'll be more interesting to see where the votes move in the last hour.

[scooter]

Yeah I didn't think much of naufragar's posts. If anything I would think a newbie wolf would be a bit more cautious early on.


That said... I do think putting some heat on a chatty newbie is probably a good strategy too because it's more likely to give us a meaningful alignment read.

[El Grillo]

Naufragar, you talk about separating your question for Serdoa from a vote on him, and perhaps that makes sense in the context of One Night Ultimate Werewolf (a game I personally haven't played, but it sounds like you only get one day lynch vote per game?), but in a forum game where your vote is all the leverage you have, you can see why it drew all this attention.

Cyneheard, you've been quiet since your random vote on scooter at the beginning. What do you think about the interactions between naufragar/Serdoa/Lewwyn, and on the reasoning of pindicator and Commodore starting a second wagon on GKC?

[Charriu]

Oh, it's been open for an hour and there's 6 pages of posts.

This might be a lot more work than I anticipated. x_x If I don't respond to things right away, it's going to be because I have a job and there's a lot of text to wade through.

-starts wading-

Oh I can totally see what you mean. Just had dinner and put the kids to bed. 7 pages after 2 and a half hours, I'm kind of overwhelmed. My first thought was to ask random.org what to do, but it looks like there are already open fronts. I trust the vets and join in on GeneralKillCavalry for now.

@pindicator: Never played WW here in the forum. Only played it in person, which I can absolutely recommend.

[Lewwyn]

Oh, it's been open for an hour and there's 6 pages of posts.

This might be a lot more work than I anticipated. x_x If I don't respond to things right away, it's going to be because I have a job and there's a lot of text to wade through.

-starts wading-

Oh I can totally see what you mean. Just had dinner and put the kids to bed. 7 pages after 2 and a half hours, I'm kind of overwhelmed. My first thought was to ask random.org what to do, but it looks like there are already open fronts. I trust the vets and join in on GeneralKillCavalry for now.

@pindicator: Never played WW here in the forum. Only played it in person, which I can absolutely recommend.

Set your forum settings to 40 posts per page.


"Trust the vets"...

[El Grillo]

History:
Serdoa votes Serdoa
Adrien votes Lewwyn
Commodore votes Serdoa
El Grillo vote naufragar
pindicator votes Rowain
naufragar votes pindicator
Cyneheard votes scooter
GKC votes Commodore
Rowain votes Lewwyn
Gaspar votes Rowain
Lewwyn votes Serdoa
GKC switches from Commodore to Cyneheard
Scooter votes Cyneheard
Rowain switches from Lewwyn to naufragar
GKC switches from Cyneheard to naufragar
Serdoa switches from Serdoa to naufragar
Lewwyn switches from Serdoa to naufragar
pindi switches from Rowain to GKC
Commodore switches from Serdoa to GKC
El Grillo switches from naufragar to Cyneheard
Charriu votes GKC

Tally:
naufragar (4): Rowain, GKC, Serdoa, Lewwyn
GKC (3): pindicator, Commodore, Charriu
Cyneheard (2): scooter, El Grillo
Rowain (1): Gaspar
Lewwyn (1): Adrien
Pindicator (1): naufragar
scooter (1): Cyneheard

not voted (4): Bob, SD, CMF, thrawn
not posted (3): Bob, SD, thrawn

[Rowain]

I agree that naufs post was super scummy by being so defensive so early. However I also think that jumping all over him reeks of a bus. So I'm going to keep my vote right where it is.

I mean what's more likely - nauf is a clumsy wolf or a confused villager? I feel like Rowain and Serdoa would know this too.

I see no mention of Lewwyn here. Strange shouldn't your logic apply to him too?

[Rowain]

Oh, it's been open for an hour and there's 6 pages of posts.

This might be a lot more work than I anticipated. x_x If I don't respond to things right away, it's going to be because I have a job and there's a lot of text to wade through.

-starts wading-

Oh I can totally see what you mean. Just had dinner and put the kids to bed. 7 pages after 2 and a half hours, I'm kind of overwhelmed. My first thought was to ask random.org what to do, but it looks like there are already open fronts. I trust the vets and join in on GeneralKillCavalry for now.

@pindicator: Never played WW here in the forum. Only played it in person, which I can absolutely recommend.

Trust the vets? Now I'm interested why you chose to trust the vets pindi and Commodore but not one of the various other vets?

[pindicator]

Charriu, what are the games like that you've played before?

[Cyneheard]

Naufragar, you talk about separating your question for Serdoa from a vote on him, and perhaps that makes sense in the context of One Night Ultimate Werewolf (a game I personally haven't played, but it sounds like you only get one day lynch vote per game?), but in a forum game where your vote is all the leverage you have, you can see why it drew all this attention.

Cyneheard, you've been quiet since your random vote on scooter at the beginning. What do you think about the interactions between naufragar/Serdoa/Lewwyn, and on the reasoning of pindicator and Commodore starting a second wagon on GKC?

That's my work schedule coming into play. Lunch being when this started was great, but had to focus on work after that. I don't know how much time I'll get during weekday work hours.

We've had One Night Werewolf on the forum, and votes moved around during the day IIRC, so that's not a great presumption El Grillo on naufr's behalf, although in person it might work differently.

I picked scooter because he's someone I know better, so I figured I'd have a chance to get a little more information out of him than someone else initially, but then wagons went off in other directions because GKC and naufragar are absolutely all over the place. The wagons on them almost make too much sense - that they're obviously being careless so let's get them because it's too easy! I want to hear more from Rowain and pindicator about why they went for their wagons.

Lewwyn's point was that Serdoa is just being Serdoa, which I know isn't all that helpful for people who don't remember him that well. Especially since the self-vote was the first post, I think starting the day with obvious nonsense to get a reaction makes sense. That's not my style but I get it - and I WANT my reunion game to start with some silliness in the first few minutes. It's not like we had anything more to go on.