Are you, in fact, a pregnant lady who lives in the apartment next door to Superdeath's parents? - Commodore

Create an account  

 
WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

(September 4th, 2020, 14:01)Lewwyn Wrote: What do you say about nauf, comm?

About as likely to be scum as you. Being on Cyneheard if you were there at deadline gushing squid ink about other people certainly isn't a get out of jail free card.
If only you and me and dead people know hex, then only deaf people know hex.

I write RPG adventures, and blog about it, check it out.
Reply

GL guys. Damn shame, I was having fun.
I've got some dirt on my shoulder, can you brush it off for me?
Reply

History
Meiz votes pindicator
pindicator votes AdrienIer
Rowain votes AdrienIer
SD votes CMF
scooter votes AdrienIer
Commodore votes AdrienIer

AdrienIer (4): pindicator,Rowain,scooter,Commodore
pindicator (1): Meiz
CMF (1): SD

not voted (7): Serdoa, Lewwyn, naufr, CMF, Charriu, AdrienIer, GKC
Reply

Town points for Meiz, Rowain, and Serdoa IMO. There was an initial push on Cyneheard, then Lewwyn kind of deflated it with a post saying that he didn't think he would get anybody to vote for Cyneheard, and then later on Meiz, Rowain, and Serdoa brought it back and picked up the steam.

AdrienIer had this post

(September 3rd, 2020, 04:45)AdrienIer Wrote: Ok I got to reread Bob and Cyneheard, I'm staying on Bob. Cyneheard had some good posts looking into people, Bob basically hasn't.

I'll be back this afternoon with reads on the bigger posters (I hope before deadline, normally it'll be ok).

Right after Cyneheard got up to 2nd place.
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player
Reply

@Rowain FYI we have the mafia helper tool up and running so you don't have to keep a manual tally anymore.

Tally as of post 456:

Lynch votes
4 votes: AdrienIer (pindicator, Rowain, scooter, Commodore)
1 votes: Pindicator (Meiz)
1 votes: Chevalier Mal Fet (superdeath)

Voting history:
Meiz Wrote: Pindicator
Rowain Wrote: Cyneheard
Rowain Wrote: Cyneheard
pindicator Wrote: AdrienIer
Rowain Wrote: AdrienIer
superdeath Wrote: Chevalier Mal Fet
scooter Wrote: AdrienIer
Commodore Wrote: AdrienIer
Reply

(September 4th, 2020, 12:58)Lewwyn Wrote: Could Adrien and Pindi both be scum? Or could both be innocent?

I doubt that both are scum. That is not the impression I get from them.
Reply

(September 4th, 2020, 14:35)BRickAstley Wrote: @Rowain FYI we have the mafia helper tool up and running so you don't have to keep a manual tally anymore.

I thought so from your test but I'm usually running a tally for me anyway and sometimes even you have to sleep or other things to do.
Reply

(September 4th, 2020, 13:42)Serdoa Wrote: So, should I comment now or do you come back later with actually anything that is not - yet again - misconstrued? Because what you ... forget ... to mention - not to say deliberately left out - is that I had gone through all Bob posts, voted him with good reasoning AND then 11 minutes later voted Cyneheard. At that point, Bob had 9 votes and in my post voting for Cyneheard I expressly mention that my vote on Bob does not change anything, that I would rather have you lynched but it doesn't seem likely to happen and so I want to pressure Cyneheard in some answers.

Basically: How can I be one of the wolves hopping from Bob to Cyneheard because Bob became a safe lynch, when I literally was on Bob for 11 minutes while he had already 8 votes and was clearly leading?

And just let me mention that as well: My vote put Cyneheard at 4, equal to SD. Without that vote, or one on you or SD instead, there would have been likely no discussion about Cyneheard, but rather if it is better to lynch a quiet newbie or an unwilling vet. So, would you like to accuse me for

a) trying to drive discussion?
b) voting for a wolf when he was not in a dangerous position?
b) voting for a wolf and putting him in a dangerous position?

Basically, what you think is innocent play I think is wolfy: I won't criticize your post on Bob for not reading him as village. Plenty of people said similar. You vote him for the common reasons, but then you take the vote tally, where it looks like Bob has 9 votes, and the next highest (Superdeath) has 4. (I made the same miscount in my post: Pindi is off Bob, so Bob's at 8.) 9 is way too high, so (this is my interpretation, as you like to point out) you realize you can and should hop off. With that many votes on Bob and given how prickly Bob has been (a no-no around here), it's quite likely he hangs. As you say, you're on him for 11 minutes before hopping off to Cyneheard, so that he talks more, in your words. You then follow up that post with your reasons for Cyneheard here, making sure to note that he has more content than Bob. I believe (and again I'm interpreting) that you voted Bob because he was the wolf bus target, tallied the vote and realized that the Bob bus was too crowded, and you hopped off to Cyneheard who was weaker but nowhere near dead (7 votes for Bob, 4 each for Superdeath and Cyneheard), so if the time ever came, you had that vote history in your pocket.

(Coincidentally, this is why I don't quite buy Scooter's caveat (which is not to speculate about Scooter himself). I think Bob was so comfortably dead that the wolves wouldn't have had to fret about the lynch hitting the number 2.)

(September 4th, 2020, 12:55)Serdoa Wrote: Lewwyn gets town-points;
Oh, wait he doesn't because before the post he got town-points for, he had not mentioned all possible meta-constellations;
But wait, he still gets town points for now, I guess because of the meta-uncertainty?

Covering all bases...

Not sure if this is a serious attack, but I'll respond to it because I apparently can't resist bait.

Lewwyn was one of the first voters (maybe the very first?) on a Cyneheard train. This was a serious attack and not a love tap. Cyneheard turned out to be a wolf. So: Cyneheard acts wolfy->Lewwyn really challenges him on it->Cyneheard turns out to be a wolf seems to give pretty strong town points to Lewwyn.

However, if there are two scum teams, wolf Lewwyn could have been jumping on something wolfy that Cyneheard did, hoping that Cyneheard was a wolf-looking villager, and just got lucky to hit a rival pack. I assumed in my earlier post that there was 1 scum team, which was an unfounded assumption. I made a mistake and would rather quickly correct myself than leave it up there for someone to grab. And apologies to the people who dislike meta-arguments.

Serdoa because I still mean what I say. I'll reread the Adrien/Pindicator stuff, so I can contribute to the current conversation.
There is no way to peace. Peace is the way.
Reply

Who would you vote for if not Serdoa, nauf?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
Reply

Lewwyn, what do you think about AdrienIer?
Suffer Game Sicko
Dodo Tier Player
Reply



Forum Jump: