WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Charriu]

This game gets crazier with every post. I'm seriously conflicted between both scooter and pindicator. I hope I get the chance to re-read both of them soon. In the mean time I want to say a few words to this:

I think anyone saying that SD is a liability and hence ought to be lynched on D2 after so many deaths is scummy, I mean come on charriu. There's juicier targets - he's just a non-entity, and lynching an active wolf misleading people is bound to cause more gain.

" Superdeath: Superdeath granted us exactly 3 more posts on day 2, even less then on day 1. Those were: A understable, but other then being voted by him, baseless vote against Chevalier (#437). A low effort defense of that accusation at (#519, with a quick backtrack on that accusation and at last he throw himself on the scooter bus without much (#638). In addition he voted late for Bob on day 1. I don't know if he's a villager or wolf, what I definitely know is that he's a burden."

Like sure, he isn't engaged, but this is D2, with so many deaths, are you seriously going to go for the low-engage vote? Like it's a bit too late to vote on that principle. Anyhow, that's a side-track.

You are absolutely correct that there are juicier targets. In fact I never even called for SD to be lynched nor did I ever vote for him again since day 1. That day 1 vote was mainly to pressure him back then, just like others did. He defended himself and I accepted his defense at (#258). And please don't understand my lists as a priority list of lynches, it is not. In fact Lewwyn asked me about this list of mine (#464) what my lynch order is and I told him so here (#469). As you can see the order is different and SD is even on the lowest spot there. Yes, I'm not trusting Superdeath and I would say I am allowed to distrust a player, who's only contributing the bare minimum. This is my main problem with SD that he just does not gives us enough participation. If he would just write a little bit more and maybe even grazes us with some of his best memes I would be perfectly happy about him.

Will I vote SD on day 3? Most likely not, because like you have already said there are juicier targets especially after the night results. Also don't forget that I wrote the post you are referring to (#685) before the night result. This night result changes a lot and it looks like it will be either pindicator or scooter today. Do I understand you correctly that you are in favor of lynching pindicator today?

[BRickAstley]

Thanks again to yuris125 for posting the night resolution in my absence.

Tally as of post 714:

Lynch votes
3 votes: scooter (Charriu, Commodore, pindicator)
3 votes: pindicator (Rowain, superdeath, scooter)

Voting history:

SCOOTER

pindicator

scooter

Pindicator

Scooter

scooter

pindicator

[GeneralKilCavalry]

I don't like any of scooter/pindicator/rowain. They are all scummy imho, but not all of them can be scum at once. My read on the state of the game interactions is this right now.

There's unresolved tension in me/serdoa vs. nauf/rowain with varying permutations of interactions going on.

Then there's the assorted group of charriu, SD, CMF, who can't be pinned down in the same way.

Finally, we have Scooter vs. Pindicator and Commodore which is the one interaction I understand the least.

If I had to guess, there's probably a wolf in each of these groups.

I still don't like some of what rowain has to say, and neither nauf/rowain have engaged with my accusations of them behaving in similar patterns since the very early game. Rowains votes are also damning, and frankly, I don't like anyone who tries to bandwagon on me without any reason, just throwing out my name on some BS obscure accusation.

I don't like scooter or pindicator either. So at the end of the day, I need to see more arguments and conversation from these people before I can vote. It looks like the main story will be scooter's wild role claim, and the fallout from that.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

people I weouuld like to lynch tomorrow:
pindicator (for the tying of cyneheard with Adrien), GKC (for the throwing mud on cyneheard but never really voting for him)

could be talked into a lynch
Commodore (easy scater), naufragar (enough posts that look scummy ), SD (is he even trying?)

on the fence
scooter - lewwyn does make some arguments but scooters explosion looked real.
charriu - I can't explain it he just feels odd to me

won't lynch:
CMF His past work should be rewarded with one day of peace

Scooter didn't explode. You scum? Yeah you might be scum. Let's reward CMF for his "hard work"? WTF? One day of peace? Set up the following day's mislynch?

Even the Pindi argument is very bad. So many better reasons for pindi to be scum than the lynch. You are pretty clearly just going through the motions at this point. What a scum post.



Lynch Scooter or Rowain or Nauf or Pindi. Pindi depends on what happens in the day discussion, but for sure Scooter is a wolf, and Rowain or pindi is my #2 after yesterday's day. Notice that Nauf is in the second tier of Rowain's scum list so it will take lynching 4 people before getting to him.

On rereading it turns out I have very little new to add - Lewwyn's thoughts mirror my own here.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

Obvs.


What a waste. Tell me how much you've gleaned from that Rowain?  

How much have you gleaned, Rowain? What have you learned from lynching with a massive bandwagon? Your voted throughout this game have been nothing but incorrect.

Wow either a serial killer or a bad vig shot.


Pindicator

What do you have to say about the night result?

SD, why the hell are you voting for pindicator right now? We need to keep the pressure on scooter .

Also, charriu, I really dislike the way you attempt to presume who I am voting for just now. It seems like a very disingenuous move.

[superdeath]

Because it is my view that since both of them have said they wanted to shoot the other, it SEEMS like both are scum/wolves and its just a last ditch effort by them both to give one of them an easy win via "hey i helped lynch a wolf!" to the end, where they continue to kill every night. So in my view? Lynch one, and hope the vig kills the other?

[GeneralKilCavalry]

But why prefer pindicator at this point?

[naufragar]

I don't like scooter or pindicator either. So at the end of the day, I need to see more arguments and conversation from these people before I can vote. It looks like the main story will be scooter's wild role claim, and the fallout from that.

SD, why the hell are you voting for pindicator right now? We need to keep the pressure on scooter .

Help. I'm not tracking. Why are you voting scooter over pindicator?

[GeneralKilCavalry]

For the same reasons as early day1, and I want to increase pressure on him over the role claim tbh. I'm not sure 100% how to treat his interactions today, but I want to carry over my earlier suspicions.

[superdeath]

But why prefer pindicator at this point?

why prefer one over the other? Because we cant lynch 2 targets.