WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Charriu]

GG scooter

[Chevalier Mal Fet]

Just invert every conclusion I made in my big wall of text posts on Commodore, scooter, and Adrien, and we should be good going forward. I'll do the same for everyone else, then just reverse my conclusions. Foolproof!

[Rowain]

I'd *love* to discuss these possibilities

Well why didn't you? Or when are you willing to discuss them?

Now. NOW THAT WE KILLED THE MOST EXHAUSTING WEREWOLF TO LYNCH EVER.

Seriously, wp Scooter.

Well where are your answers? Or is it now not before the next day and then another excuse?

[Commodore]

I'd *love* to discuss these possibilities

Well why didn't you? Or when are you willing to discuss them?

Now. NOW THAT WE KILLED THE MOST EXHAUSTING WEREWOLF TO LYNCH EVER.

Seriously, wp Scooter.

Well where are your answers? Or is it now not before the next day and then another excuse?

You'll get my last will and testament at dawn before you kill me, don't worry.

[Rowain]

I'd *love* to discuss these possibilities

Well why didn't you? Or when are you willing to discuss them?

Now. NOW THAT WE KILLED THE MOST EXHAUSTING WEREWOLF TO LYNCH EVER.

Seriously, wp Scooter.

Well where are your answers? Or is it now not before the next day and then another excuse?

You'll get my last will and testament at dawn before you kill me, don't worry.

If you don't get viged you will survive. But I'm doing the Vader-choke right now so if you feel something that's me

[Serdoa]

Well played scooter.

I did not expect that much movement. I think it did give some insights that we would not have got with just sitting around. Sorry that I was not there at the end as I had planned, I was on pain-killers and just laid down and was done. I've had another pair just now after waking back up and still feel rather bad, but I'll make sure to give my thoughts tomorrow before the night is over.

[Commodore]

Ok Comm, consider me cowed.

Scooter

We have 10 people alive now. If we mislynch, we go to 9 on the day, 7 after two night kills. I doubt there are more than 3 wolves, 1 SK alive right now. A mislynch puts us at Lynch or Lose, but then, if my understanding of the SK win condition is correct, he can’t just pop villagers or the wolves win and the SK loses.

The entire game I couldn’t figure out if I had a reason for thinking you were scummy or I just didn’t like the way you argue. You’ve pretty much done nothing but short one sentence palm readings. “So and so feels town, but I could change.” I’m not going to go through your posts, but the last thing I remember from you on GKC was “he feels town, but if not, he’s played a hell of a great first game.” Touchy feely stuff always. You’ve never read into GKC, but you’ve never really done deep dives at all. This is the first time you’ve stuck your neck out, and this goes way beyond anything you could defend by pointing to the sainted Lewwyn.

Ok. If the logic’s insoluble, we get a wolf (or some flavor of scum). If it turns out it wasn’t and Scooter flips town, I get to hop back on to GKC, with all the reasons that make him compelling today plus the fact that you saved him. Then after a GKC lynch, we can lynch you for promising your case was ironclad. If Scooter flips town, we can nab scum on the next two days? I’ll take that deal. By then we might even have a definitive answer on Pindi.

Thank you, you're beautiful, never let anyone say mean things to you.

[Commodore]

Well played scooter.

I did not expect that much movement. I think it did give some insights that we would not have got with just sitting around. Sorry that I was not there at the end as I had planned, I was on pain-killers and just laid down and was done. I've had another pair just now after waking back up and still feel rather bad, but I'll make sure to give my thoughts tomorrow before the night is over.

It was such a clever trap that half the village bumbled in to it. But please, get some rest, you can come back tomorrow ready to pull...some canines.

[GeneralKilCavalry]

I was able to re-read GKC, which was easier then expected, because he may have a lot of posts, but those are rather short. Note that this is already a tiny negative in my book.

First of all GKC was one of the players, who was defended by a known wolf (#70) early on. I know that doesn't immediately mean anything. It's just a tiny puzzle piece. We also know that there was his rule-break with the edited post on day 1, but that also was a tiny issue. To add a nother small issue is the hiccup with his vote-testing (#113) to which I have to say, you could have just tested that in the Offtopic section of the forum.

Bigger accusations came from dead villagers like Meiz (#575) and I wholeheartedly have to agree, that definitely looks like a defense for Cyneheard - a by now known wolf. In addition to that he this post reads like a deliberate jab at Bob (#267) and in the end he also voted Bob on day 1, which saved Cyneheard. On day 2 he voted nauf, which was a safe null vote.

He also claimed credit for the push on Cyneheard (#432)(#489) although he never actually voted against Cyneheard (His only vote against Cyneheard was a vote that he himself called a test and definitely falls into the early joke-vote phase). He later defended that (#578) claiming that all answers lie in (#255). But I have to say that #255 post is rather weak.

Another tiny issue from night 2, he said he wanted to post something that night, but never followed through with that (#674), which is a disappointment.

Then we have the already mentioned 8 minute posts between (#716 - #718)

All in all that also doesn't look that great for GKC. I'm still very much conflicted with now 3 people being very suspicious, but I will stay on scooter, who looks the worst right now.

This is so ****** disingenuous. Post 70 contains barely nothing about me, and my berating of SD’s choices, if we were wolves would have been in private. It was absolutely necessary to get both bandwagons in full force, and SD, being a low-attention player this game, needed to be corrected immediately. Him moving from scooter was nothing short of strange, and would’ve served to confuse the field. Imagine if a bunch of the wolves had pushed to vote SD for his careless dilly dallying between scooter to pundits. We needed players on both at the moment, and as the day evolved scooter became a clearer choice. 

I’m sorry, but those who pushed against me this night should be high on everyone’s scum radar.

[Rowain]

@GKC your posts are nearly as usefull as SD's.

Hurray we killed a wolf but we still have the problem with pindicator tomorrow and you and SD and Commodore. And we have plain simple done very little this day.

A little list to lynch: GKC, pindicator, Commodore, SD, Charriu, CMF, nauf

Most likely the only useful villager Serdoa will die tonight.

Luckily I will be traveling starting Friday so at least that reduces the time I spend here.