WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Rowain]

@Serdoa
I completely agree with your arguments above.

Problem is my voting has been abysmal bad this game. My scumdar completely broken. I don't want to led the village any further astray as for this game I have absolutely no confidence left whatever.

I still find the closeness and similarity of pindi and scooters claim extremely suspicious. For me it was too close that wolf scooter could have read pindis claim and reacted with his large post to it.

I absolutely don't like that SD can cost free through the game with nothing at all.

And if I count of you, pindi and Commodore then who is left: CMF , Charriu, naufr. All 3 would make good lynches which together with SD makes 4 top-lynch candidates which are at this point in game a tough situation for town. If I get lynched today for reasons I can understand there are 7 players left out of which come 0-2 wolves + 1 SK.
Good Luck with that.

[Rowain]

I'm now off for awhile. I can read via smartphone but I won't post from it

[BRickAstley]

Tally as of post 895:

Lynch votes
7 votes: Rowain (Commodore, Serdoa, pindicator, Chevalier Mal Fet, Rowain, Charriu, naufragar)

Voting history:

Rowain

Rowain

Rowain

Rowain

Rowain

Rowain

Rowain

[Commodore]

So here's the thing, I don't know trust Rowain at all, for obvious reasons. He's still doing his utmost to sow descent among the village. Serdoa's logic about abrasive anti-village play is sound, per forty-five past games of RB WW. I certainly hope his name flips red (or whatever a SK color is), because if he's blue then he's effectively been playing traitor with his herculean efforts to save a wolf and lynch a villager despite all logic and good sense. I don't see how we can't but lynch Rowain...but I don't have a good feeling. Could Rowain really be as worthless as Superdeath but without the sterling voting record?

I guess the real danger is Honesty Village with a 5 scum faction. In that case, Rowain better be scum and not just anti-village village, because we are at lylo. Despite the name of this scenario, the 5-wolf case of course could have Pindicator as a wolf who Scooter was trying to save. I'd ignore a lot of the wriggling on day 3 for Scooter, he was fairly doomed from the beginning, only really getting a chance when GKC was raised up as an alternative.

[Commodore]

Tally as of post 895:

Lynch votes
7 votes: Rowain (Commodore, Serdoa, pindicator, Chevalier Mal Fet, Rowain, Charriu, naufragar)

Ugh, also, no Superdeath vote for Rowain. He's never voted for anyone but a wolf at lynching time.

[Charriu]

Well voting is almost the only thing he's doing.

[Commodore]

Well voting is almost the only thing he's doing.

I really wish we were still at a stage for policy lynches. 

I know it gives an icky feeling, but honestly if I was in Rowain's shoes and I still had a packmate to safeguard, this is what I'd do. Dramatic self-vote, surly snide remarks to sow descent, then just sit back and watch the village drown in flop-sweat.

[pindicator]

I agree, I'm also having that sinking feeling. Rowain's not being helpful in his arguments and he's just tossing out names. We are going to need to go back and parse the first few days. I'm sure anything he said today is not reliable, but stuff before he was turning up on people's radars could have some information.

As for a traitor role, do traitors know the wolves ahead of time? I know when I played the Doctor Saul game I did not know at the start, but i was given a seer ability to help me find them. I don't have enough experience with these games to know what is customary, however.

[Serdoa]

So here's the thing, I don't know trust Rowain at all, for obvious reasons. He's still doing his utmost to sow descent among the village. Serdoa's logic about abrasive anti-village play is sound, per forty-five past games of RB WW. I certainly hope his name flips red (or whatever a SK color is), because if he's blue then he's effectively been playing traitor with his herculean efforts to save a wolf and lynch a villager despite all logic and good sense. I don't see how we can't but lynch Rowain...but I don't have a good feeling. Could Rowain really be as worthless as Superdeath but without the sterling voting record?

I guess the real danger is Honesty Village with a 5 scum faction. In that case, Rowain better be scum and not just anti-village village, because we are at lylo. Despite the name of this scenario, the 5-wolf case of course could have Pindicator as a wolf who Scooter was trying to save. I'd ignore a lot of the wriggling on day 3 for Scooter, he was fairly doomed from the beginning, only really getting a chance when GKC was raised up as an alternative.

Ugh, also, no Superdeath vote for Rowain. He's never voted for anyone but a wolf at lynching time.

He voted Bob D1. By my latest count, Bob was not a wolf

Nonetheless, I agree with you Comm. I don't like Rowains play, I don't like Rowains voting, but I did not expect Rowains answer to my question - I expected him to keep being upset and abrasive. I also see us being in a very bad spot if he is indeed villager, but lynching superdeath just for not playing ... seems the time has passed to do so. That said, the question has to be: Whom do we feel strongest to be a wolf or SK? I do have to question myself that as well, with GKC coming up villager, but I would also prefer to hear from the other players what they feel and think.

[Commodore]

Pindicator, I'd really like to hear more theories about Cyneheard's death that aren't serial killer.

The sole reason I'm not voting you today over Rowain is that if you *are* the serial killer you could have claimed multishot vig without anything else changing. Cyneheard was a great vigilante target, shooting him was a pretty pro-town move. The pressure to claim wasn't there, but if you were a serial killer who killed Cynheheard and then Lewwyn (or Meiz) you'd have no problem making that claim, right? Instead you leave a great mystery.