WW 46: Wolves Return to Realms Beyond

[Serdoa]

Yeah, I figured that was next to come Commodore. You have not answered any questions, you certainly won't anymore as you "solved" the game. Fine, I guess that means it is in Charrius and naufragars hands whom to believe. I know I will vote SD today and you tomorrow, if I'm still alive then.

I did expect this as soon as I stated that you could indeed lie about your doctor claim. But only after I made my last post, showing that your post clearly meant as a stab against Charriu applied to SD in full force you would have to make a daring play, because at that point, you would have to go back on your own words otherwise, which would not look good, would it?

[Commodore]

Yeah, I figured that was next to come Commodore. You have not answered any questions, you certainly won't anymore as you "solved" the game. Fine, I guess that means it is in Charrius and naufragars hands whom to believe. I know I will vote SD today and you tomorrow, if I'm still alive then.

I did expect this as soon as I stated that you could indeed lie about your doctor claim. But only after I made my last post, showing that your post clearly meant as a stab against Charriu applied to SD in full force you would have to make a daring play, because at that point, you would have to go back on your own words otherwise, which would not look good, would it?

You don't need to convince anyone that SD's been acting anti-town. I saw you lining up the mislynch on me tomorrow if the game's still ongoing then. I know you knew you weren't convincing me here, which is why your effortful post back there was aimed squarely at Naufragar. It's why I figured I'd stop it with the dangle-hams, you're no Wookie.

[Charriu]

Okay, that's sufficient wriggling for me. Naufragar, Superdeath, attend.

As anyone not spilling tons of ink inventing elaborate theories about THREE scum factions or latching convoluted never-before-heard JOAT bomb abilities can tell, the mysteries are all solved. Superdeath has been playing a hilariously anti-town game, but his quixotic targeting, as bad as it was, follows from his own comments. HE IS BELIEVABLE.

I'm sorry Commodore, but was I the first one who brought up the three scum faction theory today? No I was not, look here:

I suspect we have just one wolf remaining. Although could be two. If there is only 1, we got a good chance of winning. If there are two.... well we better lynch one today. Charriu or Nauf sound like the best candidates, unless Serdoa or Commodore have been playing the best mind-game ever.

It's Superdeath who started talking about a three scum faction. I can't believe that you trust Superdeath, who (almost) never worked in the towns favor in this game. I only thought about it because he brought it up and Naufragar asked here if there are other ways to explain the Cyneheard kill. And do I need to remind you who brought up the bomb ability today?

Cyneheard didn't have to be killed, by the way, if his JOAT had a bomb ability. He could have bombed Rowain, hilariously.

I ask you what has Superdeath ever done for us?

(And please don't say the Aqueduct   )

[Commodore]

Three scum factions, not a fraction of three scum.

[Commodore]

I've been dangling that JOAT-bomb silliness to see who bites for a while. Even Pindicator, who really should have known better, wanted to bat it around a little.

[Charriu]

In responds to the other points.

Thus, the sole remaining question I left open in my night-kill speculations, the one that I left open like I left open the silly Jack-of-all-Trades bomber theory, was that of "why did we have a night with just one kill?" Sure, Pindicator, who's been decent-to-middling at scumhunting might have shot Serdoa and I healed him, but there's still the third unexplained kill with SK, wolves, and Superdeath all killing. Except, obviously, that's not a mystery at all. THE WOLVES SHOT PINDICATOR AND HE WAS 1-SHOT BULLETPROOF.

Now this is one thing where we are at almost the same conclusion. Yes it's most likely that the wolves shot pindicator on night 3. The one thing were I disagree or at least doubt that theory is in who shot GKC. We don't know how "Sleepy" works and it could have just been pindicator shooting GKC.

This leads us to a situation where the wolves, worried, are nearing lylo but they have a killer who can target them still on the loose. They rapidly figure out that it's likely a serial killer, because mild bulletproofing is a common power for SKs to have. They can try to kill him again, but wouldn't it be better if they could lynch him?

It's not like the serial killer was mentioned from day 2. I think after at least night 2 it was not a big surprise that we might have a serial killer among us. I suspect as much on day 3 together with other I remember that I said I believe scooter to be a wolf and pindicator to be a serial killer. That's why I went for pindicator on day 4.

I will keep my vote on Superdeath, because he's the most likely anti-town player here. He even wasn't ready to risk anything for the town as he clearly stated yesterday:

and meanwhile people who are doing scummy things- or very little at all, *ahem* -are being ignored

all part of the plan

Ok, Superdeath, what is this? Care to illuminate us on your big plan?

Oh, its a small plan. It involves me not dying. Also hopefully ends with the village winning, and those stinky wolves being sent packing.

If everyone was willing to or if our Lord and Savior Commodore thought it was a smart move, id share my role and hope others do to.

He only is interested in his own survival. How could we let him live the long in this game.

[Charriu]

Three scum factions, not a fraction of three scum.

Ok sorry. I clearly misread that.

[Commodore]

It's not like the serial killer was mentioned from day 2. I think after at least night 2 it was not a big surprise that we might have a serial killer among us. I suspect as much on day 3 together with other I remember that I said I believe scooter to be a wolf and pindicator to be a serial killer. That's why I went for pindicator on day 4.

Indeed, and you were on Scooter day 3, although you were carefully signalling willingness to jump off the whole time. Good show, didn't really ping my radar until a later reread.

[Serdoa]

You don't need to convince anyone that SD's been acting anti-town. I saw you lining up the mislynch on me tomorrow if the game's still ongoing then. I know you knew you weren't convincing me here, which is why your effortful post back there was aimed squarely at Naufragar. It's why I figured I'd stop it with the dangle-hams, you're no Wookie.

Isn't that attributing to me what you do? "Lets lynch Charriu and then Serdoa." Does not seem like not lining up the lynches.
And yes, after you basically declared me the next lynch after Charriu, I knew I would not convince you. Wasn't that hard to figure out that you fair and square have either convinced yourself that SD can't be a wolf or that you are playing with him together.

Honestly, everything you posted today is basically again and again "SD has to be innocent, but THIS behavior of someone else is not", just to have someone present you with evidence that "THIS behavior" was shown by SD himself first. And when that happens, you simply ignore it and harp on the next point. And when it is again shown that SD did it, you again just move the goalposts and talk about other stuff.

[Charriu]

It's not like the serial killer was mentioned from day 2. I think after at least night 2 it was not a big surprise that we might have a serial killer among us. I suspect as much on day 3 together with other I remember that I said I believe scooter to be a wolf and pindicator to be a serial killer. That's why I went for pindicator on day 4.

Indeed, and you were on Scooter day 3, although you were carefully signalling willingness to jump off the whole time. Good show, didn't really ping my radar until a later reread.

And to whom would I have jumped off to? I would have jumped off to pindicator - a known serial killer.