WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Gaspar]

While I take you up on that tea offer, how possible is it that Comm was bussed hard day 2?

Gaspar, your thoughts on this too please

See above.

[Lewwyn]

I believe Kaiser, WK and Adrien are dead.

Kaiser is dead? Did you poison him?

Rowain, AdrienIer was not a bad target for your vig shot, but why not Pindicator or Lewwyn?

About Lewwyn 2 reasons
Shooting Lewwyn would rob the town of todays discussion. His defending and who jumps where and when will prove alot more informative then trying to lynch Adrien.
But far more importantly: No matter if Lewwyn is town or scum I thought it well possible that scum has a redirector role like in WW46 and might redirect any action from Lewwyn to for example Meiz.

About pindicator: Honestly he was equally high on my list. ( I even considered shooting one of pindi,  commodore and Kaiser on Night 1 but in the end decided it better to hold my fire and see how day 2 plays out.)  This night I decided to take the shot.  I did a lot of rereading I still don't like Adriens switch to thrawn with the expression he had not realized that a thrawn-train had started when in reality said train had exactly 3 votes 2 of which had been on for some time already. All in all I went with whom I voted for on Day 2.

I like the reasoning. Even if I die I promise to be a good soldier.

[Lewwyn]

I cant believe I forgot to vote Lewwyn

BTW are you just going to sit on me all day Meiz?

[Gaspar]

I should add, that while I'm certain there are scum on Commodore, a full on bussing makes no sense because 1. Commodore had a very good role and 2. Scum already lost their traitor on D1, the only way the scum are brazen enough to bus before they've gotten even one true mislynch is a scenario where there are 5+ scum and the only scenario where that works is one where we have like 2 seers, 2 doctors and a bunch more power and I'm not seeing that.

So long story short: scum on Commodore - yes; bus on Commodore - no.

[Meiz]

Or.... was it because he was the running candidate next to Commodore?

Explain that line of thought.

WarriorKnight was the competing lynch to Scum-Commodore, thus gaining town credit for it. Somethign I'm missing?

I'll keep voting for the player I see as most likely scum. At the moment that's you Lewwyn. If your question is, am I going to shut up on commenting others while my vote is on you, no I won't.

[Lewwyn]

I should add, that while I'm certain there are scum on Commodore, a full on bussing makes no sense because 1. Commodore had a very good role and 2. Scum already lost their traitor on D1, the only way the scum are brazen enough to bus before they've gotten even one true mislynch is a scenario where there are 5+ scum and the only scenario where that works is one where we have like 2 seers, 2 doctors and a bunch more power and I'm not seeing that.

So long story short:  scum on Commodore - yes; bus on Commodore - no.

Which is A) what scum Gaspar would want everyone to believe and B) fairly true and good reasoning. It's the same reasoning I used when putting together my scum list last night. It's why I consider Jabbz to be pretty scummy.



FWIW I'm not sure of my game plan yet today. I'm not sure who to chase first to get the most info. I'm going to have to think out loud for a bit.

[pindicator]

I should add, that while I'm certain there are scum on Commodore, a full on bussing makes no sense because 1. Commodore had a very good role and 2. Scum already lost their traitor on D1, the only way the scum are brazen enough to bus before they've gotten even one true mislynch is a scenario where there are 5+ scum and the only scenario where that works is one where we have like 2 seers, 2 doctors and a bunch more power and I'm not seeing that.

So long story short:  scum on Commodore - yes; bus on Commodore - no.

Thanks that's more what I was meaning than what you detailed in the bullet point post.

[Lewwyn]

Or.... was it because he was the running candidate next to Commodore?

Explain that line of thought.

WarriorKnight was the competing lynch to Scum-Commodore, thus gaining town credit for it. Somethign I'm missing?

I'll keep voting for the player I see as most likely scum. At the moment that's you Lewwyn. If your question is, am I going to shut up on commenting others while my vote is on you, no I won't.

A) I don't think WK was cleared AT ALL. B) There are others that have gotten more town cred for lynching commodore who were more vocal thus making it a head scratcher that WK was the one killed based on your logic. I mean you think that pin and Comm are both scum and they were both on the block together. The idea that WK and Comm could be scum together isn't a concern? Or we are just cherry picking when to harbor concern or not?

[Meiz]

WK was also one main element in getting Commodore lynched, so I can easily see why scum would like to get rid of him. Disagree with that as well?

[Lewwyn]

@Gaspar the fact that you are voting for Cyne and chasing him down makes me less suspicious of you. Sure you might come back around and vote for me in the end and that may be your plan, but at least you are showing that there's more than one person to lynch. I think you should think about Meiz a bit more closely. It's part of what I'm going to do today. His inflexibility and willingness to make assertions to fit his specific world view and throw out others makes me suspicious. Sure I know the onus is on me to actually prove that, but just be more aware of it. Unless you're both scum than feel free to ignore me.