WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Meiz]

I'd like to remind you that my tunneling caught us a wolf (not saying it was all me, I think town players have been nciely on the same page in this game so far).

[Lewwyn]

WK was also one main element in getting Commodore lynched, so I can easily see why scum would like to get rid of him. Disagree with that as well?

Yes I don't think WK was a main element of it. I didn't think his attack on Commodore was particularly convincing. Obviously I was wrong about his point since he was both a villager and comm was scum, but from where I'm standing there were more important drivers to the commodore lynch.

[Rowain]

Rowain that was a good shot regardless of outcome.  Kind of wish you had used it on me instead.

While I take you up on that tea offer, how possible is it that Comm was bussed hard day 2?

I find it hard to believe that scum would happily bus a roleblocker in a role-heavy game. Of course exprience says on the 10 votes on C in the end there will be 1 scum at least.

the 10 voters: Meiz, Gaspar, Alhambram, sunrise089, novice, WarriorKnight, Jabbz, Gold Ergo Sum, Rowain, Kaiser

Of those my own vote and Kaiser come so late they didn't matter in the lynch but I do believe Kaisers story and I know my role. Meiz and Gaspar have been on him quite some time Gaspar already on Day1
Alhambram and sunrise were on it early. WK is town. Leaves GES, Jabbz and novice. From those I had GES and novice in my townbook. Jabbz whose vote was also not really convincing. But he made so many mistakes that I rather think of him of drowning townie trying hard to stay afloat.

So I wouldn't be surprised to have an error in there. If so then I would guess novice or GES but I don't see it.

[novice]

Rowain, AdrienIer was not a bad target for your vig shot, but why not Pindicator or Lewwyn?

About Lewwyn 2 reasons
Shooting Lewwyn would rob the town of todays discussion. His defending and who jumps where and when will prove alot more informative then trying to lynch Adrien.
But far more importantly: No matter if Lewwyn is town or scum I thought it well possible that scum has a redirector role like in WW46 and might redirect any action from Lewwyn to for example Meiz.

About pindicator: Honestly he was equally high on my list. ( I even considered shooting one of pindi,  commodore and Kaiser on Night 1 but in the end decided it better to hold my fire and see how day 2 plays out.)  This night I decided to take the shot.  I did a lot of rereading I still don't like Adriens switch to thrawn with the expression he had not realized that a thrawn-train had started when in reality said train had exactly 3 votes 2 of which had been on for some time already. All in all I went with whom I voted for on Day 2.

That's fair. The vote was just for dramatic effect.

I will join Gaspar on Cyneheard, who was my candidate for third scum until I noticed Adrien's terrible voting record.

[Lewwyn]

I'd like to remind you that my tunneling caught us a wolf (not saying it was all me, I think town players have been nciely on the same page in this game so far).

It's easy to be right if you have all the answers.

[Gaspar]

I had WK as likely town before he died because he was the opposite to Commodore, but certainly not full confirmed. I would say he's either dead because of his night post/who he suspected, dead because he was a villager who was less likely to be protected or dead because someone redirected the kill onto him. The last point seems weird.

For the record, since I'm a bit all over the place, my current prevailing theory is that two of Lewwyn, Pindicator and Cyneheard are scum and then one of Jabbz, GES or Kaiser are scum. Hence why I'm voting for Cyneheard right now.

[Meiz]

WK was also one main element in getting Commodore lynched, so I can easily see why scum would like to get rid of him. Disagree with that as well?

Yes I don't think WK was a main element of it. I didn't think his attack on Commodore was particularly convincing. Obviously I was wrong about his point since he was both a villager and comm was scum, but from where I'm standing there were more important drivers to the commodore lynch.

No he was very convincing, probably since his thoughts on commodore & views on other players were almost identical to mine

[Lewwyn]

For the record, since I'm a bit all over the place, my current prevailing theory is that two of Lewwyn, Pindicator and Cyneheard are scum and then one of Jabbz, GES or Kaiser are scum.  Hence why I'm voting for Cyneheard right now.

I agree that I think at least one of Pin and Cyne are scum possibly both. I also agree that one or two of Jabbz, GES and Kaiser are scum.

I also think that this makes me more confident you're not scum.

[Alhambram]

GG Warriorknight, at least you are able to do one more act till curtains fall at end of day 3.

And I am really suprised that AdrienIer turned out be hero, I got really a bad feeling from him, especially at day 2 when he attacked me and Warriorknight.
His voting behaviour seemingly confirm my suspicions, but at my long post of #970 I said in day 2 final result votes that AdrienIer might be clueless hero being used and I am baffled that it turned out be right....

GG AdrienIer

I think that I am going take bit time to re-evaluate my post 970 since AdrienIer didn't turn out be a villain.

And to answer some questions/remarks:

Important: I think I'm a decent night target so I want to state that I'm a Neighbor with Alhambram. Not a Mason, he could be scum (or, from his perspective, I could). Alhambram has been perfectly neighborly though our thread has been very inactive as he's been busy and I've either been active here or away. But I did want to confirm he posted a draft of his big post above yesterday. I say that because he comes to several of the same conclusions WK does, and to be fair to Alhambram I wanted to note that he had the thoughts first in our thread.

Frist thing: I confirm that I am neighbor with Sunrise. Due his low content posting of day 2, I was bit afraid that he might suffer same fate as Gazglum at first night. Hence I left some breadcrumbs at long post #970: my first 2 sentences include words "till morning" at morning sunrise happens and word "vicinity" which also can means neighborhoods --> neighbor.
I also confirm that our thread has been inactive, due my busy days at WW day 1 and Sunrise taking care of Frosty at WW day 2. I indeed drafted post yesterday before Warriorknight posted. Warriorkinght and me seemed reached almost same conculsions regarding AdrienIer, Pindicator and Lewwyn. It turned out that both were wrong about AdrienIer!
I also confirm that Sunrise just being neighbor is all I know about him. I don't know whether he is hero or scum, but his first day left good impression upon me and his 2nd day too.

Question for you. Did Allhambram agree with you to reveal you guys are neighbors? Did he know you were going to reveal both of you today?

I could answer you that, but I left before deadline for dinner and after deadline I returned here. So Sunrise might posted somthing before deadline, I did say that I left some breadcrumbs at my post.
I intended to answer your question by checking my and Sunrise's quicktopic right now, but bizarrely it is blocked for me right now with 500 internal server error message. Brick can you check it?
If quicktopic comes back online, then I can answer your question.

[Alhambram]

For clarification I didn't argee to reveal now, only saying that I left some breadcrumbs. I need to check quicktopic again, maybe I did miss something but 500 internal error keeps showing up for quicktopic.