WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[sunrise089]

Sorry for thread spam, that’s what I get for trying to be poetic

My vote lean is pindicator. I need to read that whole Day 2 exchange Lewwyn is quoting above and I need to go back as I said above and check the darn dolphin stuff and finally settle that. After that are Jabbz/Lewwyn/Kaiser in roughly that order. Gaspar has fallen down the list, or at least it seems wrong to lynch him before Pindicator given all the Com+Pind stuff. I am unlikely to vote for Cyneheard based on what I’ve seen so far, but again there’s tons of time left and while I read the posts Gaspar criticized tonight I’ll look again tomorrow when less tired to see if there’s more there that’s objectionable.

[sunrise089]

Big role claim there. Who hasn’t claimed? I’m certainly not village leader but I personally think we should maybe slow the early-day claims just a bit And, if there’s consensus to put the rest of the claims out there I favor an agreed upon claim order.

[Meiz]

I agree, though I think my role is useless due to the hiding aspect, and feel it's biggest benefit is the relevance to Gazglum kill.

[sunrise089]

I agree, though I think my role is useless due to the hiding aspect, and feel it's biggest benefit is the relevance to Gazglum kill.

Yep, point taken. I think in hindsight had you said you had a claim which was relevant to the discussion and wanted to propose a claim order yourself I think people would have fallen in line. But I also should have discussed my claim reveal more too so I can’t really complain

[Meiz]

I agree, though I think my role is useless due to the hiding aspect, and feel it's biggest benefit is the relevance to Gazglum kill.

Yep, point taken. I think in hindsight had you said you had a claim which was relevant to the discussion and wanted to propose a claim order yourself I think people would have fallen in line. But I also should have discussed my claim reveal more too so I can’t really complain

I'm personally sure what the benefit of mass role treveal would be for town, as I don't think we can draw heavy conclusions from player alignments based from roles. I think the normal scum hunting should be enough at this point.

[Rowain]

@Rowain, you haven’t voted, right? I know Lewwyn doesn’t look good from Day 2 and now there’s a Cyneheard train but based on earlier statements you should be pretty firm for Pindicator, no? I was on mobile a lot today so apologies if I missed you touching on this.

Part of the reason to not shoot Lewwyn was to have discussions going on. Jumping on pindi with all force would be counterproductive. With the WK kill and ADrien turning up blue I get a bad feeling and want to rethink several aspects of this game. I still think lynching pindi is the right course but I want to reevaluate that.

[Gold Ergo Sum]

WK narrowly edging GES for game MVP.

Omar don't have the energy to step up his game any more on this front.  Forever the bridesmaid.  

Or in other words, Gaspar is starting to show an agenda of avoiding Lew/Pind lynches and instead pushing CyneHeard/Kaiser lynches which makes me even more (and how is that even possible) interested in the two lynches I prefer to occur next.

Omar had the same thought.  Yesterday, Doc and Weeb Fox were like some old married couple bickering and griping and throwing accusations.  Omar half expect one of them to push their dinner aside and storm off to bed.  Trouble in 55 paradise.  

So what changed?   Neither were at risk then.  Now village got Weeb Fox dead to rights and suddenly he got a village feel to Doc?  Mmm hmm.


Omar's first three Barksdales after D1:

1) Swanson--Oops.  Still cannot believe that brother was village.  Omar don't think most villains could seem as villainous if they tried.

2) Old Tea Man--Despite all the crazy theories, only one that makes sense is the obvious one.  He the vig.  Babe Ruth called his shot.  Sadly, video evidence show it flew just outside the foul pole.  Omar missed his read on Old Tea Man too.  That said, by D2 Omar found Old Dirty T way less shady.

3) Robot--Omar still not certain about Robot.  Why did he show up after reviewing and vote Swanson, who had no chance of going down?  And then switch to be the 10th(!) vote on Flip.  This after he voted Q D1 despite saying he thought he might be village.  He had Bee-Boy on his suspects list in his huge post at 276, so he could have voted another person he was suspicious of if Q seemed less so.  Two days, two odd votes.  Also, and easily the most lynchable offense, was that font color.  Omar strain his eyes enough trying to read this stuff in his hidey hole.  Lighting bad up in here.  Help a brother out.  Policy lynch of all policy lynches.

Omar still think Kaiser shady.  Not lynchable shady at present, but someone to watch.

Omar three D2 Barksdales:

1) Swanson--Oops again.  Sorry brother.

2) Jabbz--I still have not seen a single thing out of Jabbz, other than the vote on Flip, to suggest he is village.  Of course, I haven't seen anything to suggest he's alive either.

3) Simp--Omar think he seem like a friend of the village based on posts 1041 and 1073.  Plus Omar feel Talking Dog is village and he had way more opportunity to assess  Simp than Omar.  Definitely think there was a language barrier here that threw Omar.   Omar hear a lot of junkie gibberish in west Bal'more, but most of it in English at least.  Maybe Omar give Simp the Bal'more Rosetta Stone come Secret Santa.

So of Omar's priors, Robot and Jabbz still seem possible villains.

Omar felt a pretty clear village vibe on Kardashian but the noose around his neck for now.  That's...unexpected.  But given Omar thought Swanson dirty as can be, some time tomorrow will be put into re-scrutinizing Kard.

[Meiz]

Omar had the same thought.  Yesterday, Doc and Weeb Fox were like some old married couple bickering and griping and throwing accusations.  Omar half expect one of them to push their dinner aside and storm off to bed.  Trouble in 55 paradise.  

So what changed?   Neither were at risk then.  Now village got Weeb Fox dead to rights and suddenly he got a village feel to Doc?  Mmm hmm.

There are fancy distancing plays for wolves, and then there's a point where town's plan for the lynchings becomes unbearable. I think we're at that point in this game, which causes Gaspar's agenda to change as well.

[Meiz]

Who's Kardashian ?

[WarriorKnight]

Weeb Fox is indeed scummy, but this is a legit question for any town to ask. Who did you track last night?

Omar stayed holed in his safe house last night.  No following through the shadows.  

Again, Duo Puppet, if you want Omar to lay out his reasoning, he glad to oblige, but Omar figure there some decent reasons not to elaborate too, you feel.  But Omar not one to deny a dying man his last wishes.

On that note...Weeb Fox

A fair point. Just remember crucial information not shared with village may not ever reach them if you get killed by surprise, I'm likely the only exception to that rule. But I'll leave it at that.