WW48: Melllvar's Grand Competition!

[Meiz]

Death's are not informed by PM's as far as I know.

I wonder what my plan would have been on framing you?

I am not allowed to quote Brick here I believe, but you can check post 1 of this thread for this line "Players must check their PMs and make sure they're alive each game day before posting.

I know what the rule is, I'm saying that I didn't check the PM because afaik deaths are not informed by PM and I just saw novice's deaths and assumed game on. So the rule is for "Check PM & check if you are dead which are separate things IMO. It was my mistake on posting before checking the PM.

After going through Kaiser's posts again, I agree the play doesn't make much sense for scum-Kaiser. Assumign that I was targeted with wolf power, it doesn't make sense for him to do a fake check against me either, as he would know in advance what would be about to happen. I think I'm wrong on scum-Kaiser idea.

[Kaiser]

I disagree heavily here, as scum you would know that if I had visited you, the only action I could have confirmed was someone visiting you with a role-stripping power.

That means by using such a power on Meiz and me confirming it, you would have gained immense town credit without endangering to disclose the wolf with the power. Especially with me likely ending up as the next night kill showing my town alignment.

I also encourage everyone to look at Night1, Day2 to see how the Commodore train developed and how Meiz and Rowain acted around it. I am getting warier by the minute about these two defendinding Meiz together the way they do.

[Kaiser]

btw I will be out for a walk but will come back early enough before deadline to help some more

[Meiz]

I disagree heavily here, as scum you would know that if I had visited you, the only action I could have confirmed was someone visiting you with a role-stripping power.

That means by using such a power on Meiz and me confirming it, you would have gained immense town credit without endangering to disclose the wolf with the power. Especially with me likely ending up as the next night kill showing my town alignment.

I also encourage everyone to look at Night1, Day2 to see how the Commodore train developed and how Meiz and Rowain acted around it. I am getting warier by the minute about these two defendinding Meiz together the way they do.

That would require wolves to guess in advance that you would be targeting me. Otherwise it's just a ripping of pwoer as a gambit for pulling a town-credit.

[Alhambram]

There is 7 hours left before deadline. All what I ask is players to think for themselves when and how the idea that Lewwyn/Commodore/Pindicator is scum team did start because it did led to mislynching of Lewwyn.

The answer is pretty clear to me. Lewwyn had a very heavy impact on pushing lynches away from Commodore. Pindicator had no interest in suspecting or going after Commodore. Even on Day 1 when he was a lynch candidate and Commodore was the running candidate before thrawn. I find it very suspicious that he claims he never took a look at Commodore's post, because his dolphin RP was too distracting.

Knowing that Lewwyn is a town, why did he feel need to rehammer thrawn at day 1?

[Meiz]

- Meiz #632 points that the hidden alignment helps wolves, I ask him later why but do not remember to see an answer to my questions (please correct me here Meiz)

I think I've answered this, but I don't see why not hide the information? It's just an added unknown for town early in the game.

[Meiz]

There is 7 hours left before deadline. All what I ask is players to think for themselves when and how the idea that Lewwyn/Commodore/Pindicator is scum team did start because it did led to mislynching of Lewwyn.

The answer is pretty clear to me. Lewwyn had a very heavy impact on pushing lynches away from Commodore. Pindicator had no interest in suspecting or going after Commodore. Even on Day 1 when he was a lynch candidate and Commodore was the running candidate before thrawn. I find it very suspicious that he claims he never took a look at Commodore's post, because his dolphin RP was too distracting.

Knowing that Lewwyn is a town, why did he feel need to rehammer thrawn at day 1?

Why Lewwyn had the need to hammer thrawn? I don't understand your question

[Alhambram]

There is 7 hours left before deadline. All what I ask is players to think for themselves when and how the idea that Lewwyn/Commodore/Pindicator is scum team did start because it did led to mislynching of Lewwyn.

The answer is pretty clear to me. Lewwyn had a very heavy impact on pushing lynches away from Commodore. Pindicator had no interest in suspecting or going after Commodore. Even on Day 1 when he was a lynch candidate and Commodore was the running candidate before thrawn. I find it very suspicious that he claims he never took a look at Commodore's post, because his dolphin RP was too distracting.

Knowing that Lewwyn is a town, why did he feel need to rehammer thrawn at day 1?

Why Lewwyn had the need to hammer thrawn? I don't understand your question  

Or you are avoiding my question.

[Meiz]

??

If you're askign why Lewwyn felt the need to hammer thrawn, the question is that Lewwyn believed thrawn was playing scummy and he was right.

[Rowain]

So lets us assume for a moment that Kaiser is town.

Then what?

Lets us just say Meiz and Kaiser both town and my assumption correct then we have too few scum (recap: Ass 1: pindi,GES,jabbz town, Ass 2: gaspar town Ass3: only 1 of the neighbors scum)

So if both Meiz and Kaiser are town then 1 of my believes has to be wrong. Nr 3 is the one I'm the most sure to be true.