[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[novice]

But from all I have heard I like the rogues vote on the sorcerer the least. Serdoa

You think he should have remembered the events back in ‘46? Or is there another reason?

[novice]

That is indeed the question, good Ser De Glum. We just saw how 'easy' it was to hide behind this so-called 'role-playing', which makes Cacofonix a prime suspect. Other than that, I would expect them to either hide behind others arguments, or just hide in plain sight by blowing smoke.

Faking a post restriction is a fun way to distort your footprint as scum, I’ve done it myself if I recall correctly. On the other hand, our current GM is exactly the type to actually hand out such restrictions, and if the bard’s ability gets verified, that lends further credence to his implicit claim. And even if the restriction is entirely self-imposed, he could still be town. After all he’s playing with Superdeath, who’s vigged him in the past just to get him to shut up.

[novice]

A tiebreaker power? Interesting... I'm happy with you giving it to anyone willing to trial it tonight (not me). Since you are telling us this early on Day 1 instead of keeping it to yourself I give you the slightest of town leans for now, subject to actually seeing it used in action.

History has taught us not to assume that Lewwyn makes stupid scum mistakes. Making obvious protown moves such as coming forward with such an ability is scumming 101. If anything he would be more eager as scum to make this obviously correct use of his ability.

[Serdoa]

You handing out freebies quite easily. Not many left who you would kill. But from all I have heard I like the rogues vote on the sorcerer the least. Serdoa

I mean novice already asked but I'm interested myself as well. What is your reasoning to vote on me?

Also novice, maybe not provide in your questions already an answer for the one you question? It's kinda hard to get an idea of why someone did something if you also have to ask yourself if what he claims is his own thoughts or if he just happily takes the straw you provided. And while I am at it, what should I remember from WW46? I hope not the play of anyone, because as you remember I was a wolf and I really did not care about what the villagers did in that game. (If I remember correctly I got in a discussion with naufragar on D1 and used that to be active).

Else I really see not much going on till now. Mostly roleplay that I am happy for you guys if you enjoy it, but it also means that several players have not actually participated in the actual game nor made a vote that was meant as such - or at least I assume so. SD comes to mind here. Gazglum I feel is happily giving many players a pass (Lewwyn, Dark Savant, Tarkeel IIRC). While I don't agree with the latter (I think I made my stance on "saving" newbies clear by now), especially the former I am questioning. We know that roles were rolled before alignment, so that role alone is not indicating anything in terms of scum or not. His play himself for me is also not indicating anything, it is typical hyper-active Lewwyn. It also make sense that he reveals it, no matter his alignment, as it would become obvious that something is afoot when someone talks in tongues and we see a tie-breaker on the tally. Additionally he did ask who wants it, but then was very quick to give it to novice who in turn was quick to ask for it. That might be coincidence, but I'm questioning why not wait till we could discuss it a little - making sure that it appears as if it was open for discussion when it wasn't in actuality?

[Tarkeel]

Discussion of powers might be slightly premature, but does anyone have any thoughts on that dedicated graveyard?

• DEAD PARTY MEMBERS ARE NOT TO ENTER THE LURKER THREAD UPON DEATH. THERE WILL BE A SEPARATE DEAD-ONLY GRAVEYARD THREAD FOR LYNCH AND NIGHTKILL VICTIMS
  

[Gazglum]

I'm not giving Lewwyn a town pass, I can't tell anything from his songs. I just wanted to see him curse someone. If I think he slips up and shows wolf I'll still vote him. I won't vote the newbies.

[Gazglum]

As for the graveyard, I am keenly hoping for a SPEAK WITH DEAD spell.

[novice]

Also novice, maybe not provide in your questions already an answer for the one you question? It's kinda hard to get an idea of why someone did something if you also have to ask yourself if what he claims is his own thoughts or if he just happily takes the straw you provided. And while I am at it, what should I remember from WW46? I hope not the play of anyone, because as you remember I was a wolf and I really did not care about what the villagers did in that game. (If I remember correctly I got in a discussion with naufragar on D1 and used that to be active).

Point taken, I tend to do that even if it’s not always ideal. But it’s also a way to encourage reticent posters to elaborate.

Yes, you were supposed to remember thrawn’s play.

[novice]

As for the graveyard, I am keenly hoping for a SPEAK WITH DEAD spell.

My first thought was a revival spell, either way I’m sure it will be interesting.

[Tarkeel]

As for the graveyard, I am keenly hoping for a SPEAK WITH DEAD spell.

My first thought was a revival spell, either way I’m sure it will be interesting.

My first thoughts was either the cleric has resurrection or the warlock has raise dead, but I think a scroll of resurrection is more likely. Speak with the dead sounds more balanced, but if someone were to come back from the dead I think we should not assume that the process was flawless.