[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[Lewwyn]

I'm sorry Cacofonix, but I tried to be clear that I wasn't so much voting for thrawn as against the monk, barbarian and ranger. I would happily vote to lynch the warlock if I thought it was happening.

Thank you for your clarity,
A single issue voter that i see.
You are against a ranger lynch as well?
Is there something more there you can tell?

[AdrienIer]

I agree Lewwyn, it can be argued that Rowain wouldn't defend a teammate too hard as scum so scum thrawn isn't hand-in-the-jar material, and on the opposite scum Rowain could have defended town thrawn (after all he'd know thrawn wasn't scum).
It yet remains that the least helpful players today have been DS and thrawn...

Yes you are right they have been least helpful,
But there is a difference between unhelpful and missing.
I guess thrawn did return to make a joke 
But I was sure he’d be back again and not leave us listing.

Yeah honestly when I last posted before going to sleep I was angry at the lurkers for lurking, but certain that they'd show up before I woke up. A vote against them is a waste of a day, whether wolf or town (or third party). After all

Don’t you want to win?

I want to play !

[Tarkeel]

I agreed that the ranger's disappearance does not look good, but I don't think it looks like a munchkin. There are bigger 'kins to hang first.

[pindicator]

@Tarkeel, what about the Barbarian?

I was about to say how Thrawn seems the type to post whatever pops into his head - which got him a lot of heat in WW47. However, I remembered the replacement request in 46 and how he felt overwhelmed before even really digging into that game. I would definitely suspect that is what is happening here with thrawn and if I had to pick a side for him today I would say he is villager and feeling overwhelmed again.

(Which side note, if it really is the case, I feel bad for. Thrawn, if that's what is going on and you read this then don't worry how you do, just play. You had a lot of fun in 47, and I hope you can have fun here again. It's tough not having all the answers as town, and toughest the first days when you really feel the most lost. But it's like a long journey, you take just one small step at a time. And that's what makes it fun in the end too. Anyway, I hope you are having fun.)

[Serdoa]

Tarkeel, feel free to elaborate what you think about my thoughts. Especially about pindicator, our Cleric. The same goes for everyone else of course. I didn't write that post just to have everyone skim it and just make a mental checkmark besides my name... At least look at the pindicator part, after all I moved my vote because I think he deserved it for that one game-related post he made.

[Serdoa]

Btw: pindi, I'm happy to hear your thoughts as well. Maybe I misunderstood something you posted back then?

[Lewwyn]

I’m not getting traction on Rowain
But if more came, I’d go back again.

If people really want a policy lynch
Why not DS over thrawn?
We have time before our launch
I think DS has been more wrong.

He has less posts, but he’s made a vote.
He disappeared when called out. 
I think he’s more likely scum of the two.
I’d vote for Dark Savant as a munchinkin lout.

[novice]

To be honest I don't know if anyone deserves to be bum-rushed at this point to avoid lynching one of the absentees. I guess I prefer to lynch thrawn over DS, since thrawn showed up and posted, whereas DS completely disappeared, but either one is fine. (Voting DS currently just to promote him as an alternative.)

Serdoa, I read your points on Pindicator and I agree that there are inconsistencies. But see above.

[novice]

I haven't clicked that link, as I'm pretty sure sharing external documents is against the rules. Maybe just post its contents here?

[novice]

Didn't know it's against the rules. But editing is also against the rules so Commodore or Brick can delete it if they want.

It's the forum posts extracted in a spreadsheet with easy tagging and filtering by tag. Thought it would help but I'm still hating it... :/

Are you hating the game as well? What's happening?