[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[novice]

That case read like 80% roleplay to me. You were serious?

[Serdoa]

Tally as of 11:39 CDT 10/26/2020:

Lynch votes
5 votes: Thrawn (WarriorKnight, superdeath, AdrienIer, Gazglum)
2 votes: Dark Savant (novice, Lewwyn)
1 votes: Superdeath (Tarkeel)
1 votes: Rowain (pindicator)
1 votes: AdrienIer (Dark Savant)
1 votes: Novice (Rowain)
1 votes: Pindicator (Serdoa)

5 votes for thrawn but only 4 names listed? Is that an error or is some power at work here?

[novice]

I think your vote matters Serdoa, it’s pretty tied between DS and thrawn AFAICT.

[Tarkeel]

Tarkeel what’s your case on Superdeath?

From 223:

Dear warlock Momonga,
The thoughts you have offered up have been sorely based on class-ist assumptions, yet you casually flinging accusations of skating by on others who have brought more to the discussion. For some reason you think of myself as a healer, but seem to forget that druids also have other strengths. You also seem awfully preoccupied with distributing the loot before it has even dropped. That for me is the mark of a munchkin.

The main contribution was a feel for each role based purely on class, while accusing others (including myself) of skating by. There were a few attempts to engage in hypothetical loot distribution, which seemed very odd. For me this feels like someone pretending to investigate and participate without actually doing anything of value. There was also a slight push-back on my initial vote, but none thereafter.

It's not the strongest case, but it seems stronger than lynching someone who found himself in deeper water than anticipated.

Not the game, I love playing offline but all the reading and jumping back and forth does my head in. Thought the smaller game would be better but not really...

Yeah, I hear that.

I'm really sorry this isn't fun

Maybe just nibbling at the edges? Focusing on a couple players and seeing if you agree with them or not, suspect them or not - then moving on from there?

Agreed with our Cleric, I've been trying to build just a feel in the back of my branches to see where to go fishing.

[pindicator]

Dark Savant

Strongly disagree, Serdoa

[novice]

Tarkeel what’s your case on Superdeath?

From 223:

Dear warlock Momonga,
The thoughts you have offered up have been sorely based on class-ist assumptions, yet you casually flinging accusations of skating by on others who have brought more to the discussion. For some reason you think of myself as a healer, but seem to forget that druids also have other strengths. You also seem awfully preoccupied with distributing the loot before it has even dropped. That for me is the mark of a munchkin.

The main contribution was a feel for each role based purely on class, while accusing others (including myself) of skating by. There were a few attempts to engage in hypothetical loot distribution, which seemed very odd. For me this feels like someone pretending to investigate and participate without actually doing anything of value. There was also a slight push-back on my initial vote, but none thereafter.

It's not the strongest case, but it seems stronger than lynching someone who found himself in deeper water than anticipated.

I thought what Superdeath posted there was pure roleplay. So he’s barely posted anything of substance, but I wouldn’t use the contents of his roleplay against him.

[Commodore]

Tally as of 11:39 CDT 10/26/2020:

Lynch votes
5 votes: Thrawn (WarriorKnight, superdeath, AdrienIer, Gazglum)
2 votes: Dark Savant (novice, Lewwyn)
1 votes: Superdeath (Tarkeel)
1 votes: Rowain (pindicator)
1 votes: AdrienIer (Dark Savant)
1 votes: Novice (Rowain)
1 votes: Pindicator (Serdoa)

5 votes for thrawn but only 4 names listed? Is that an error or is some power at work here?

Operator error.

[Commodore]

Deadline

[Tarkeel]

Like I said, it's not the strongest of cases. It's mainly the lack of relevant contribution while hiding behind roleplay.

[Commodore]

Tally as of 12:00 CDT 10/26/2020:

Lynch votes
4.1 votes: Thrawn (WarriorKnight, superdeath, Serdoa, Gazglum)
4 votes: Dark Savant (novice, Lewwyn, AdrienIer, pindicator)
1 votes: Superdeath (Tarkeel)
1 votes: AdrienIer (Dark Savant)
1 votes: Novice (Rowain)

You have all argued and debated, and it’s time. Thrawn had to leave, had to be a munchkin. As he walks away, you all seize his character sheet.
Thrawn has been kicked out. He was a Player.

Player - Welcome, Thrawn. you are a Player.
Sorcerer: Charm Person- Each night, chose one target, who cannot target you with killing or blocking abilities.
Win condition: You win when there are no longer any threats to the Players and there is at least one Player alive.

“Great job, guys. Anyway, I rolled up your loot, looks like you got a:

Scroll of Speak With Dead (1-shot Tree Stumper)
Use at night on a formerly dead player. The dead player is able to speak and participate in the game thread (in addition to the graveyard thread) for the next day. The dead player is not able to cast votes or use powers.

...talk among yourselves who gets it, I’m going to be working on the next encounter.”