[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[novice]

Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.

Pindicator

[Rowain]

Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.

Pindicator

Thats a lynch I can get aboard with.

If you don't mind:
Why is he a better lynch than superdeath for you?

[Serdoa]

Could Lewwyn play my lover sweet? Sure, he could.

Sweet-tempered Rowain met query with spite 
Ready was I to offer him my blade 
Still today would I think that justice mete 
But my doubt-gnawed heart beats yet afraid

You would offer your blade to Rowain - as in: To put it in his guts or to defend him against others?

He was suspecting Rowain yesterday, but elected to vote thrawn prior to going to bed. You can read about it from Post 234 and onwards.

I can't still parse the second part. "Still today would I think that justice mete ... " - What does that mean? I'm sure it is fine poetry but for a simple mind like myself (and with the language barrier on top) impossible to understand.

[Rowain]

Could Lewwyn play my lover sweet? Sure, he could.

Sweet-tempered Rowain met query with spite 
Ready was I to offer him my blade 
Still today would I think that justice mete 
But my doubt-gnawed heart beats yet afraid

You would offer your blade to Rowain - as in: To put it in his guts or to defend him against others?

He was suspecting Rowain yesterday, but elected to vote thrawn prior to going to bed. You can read about it from Post 234 and onwards.

I can't still parse the second part. "Still today would I think that justice mete ... " - What does that mean? I'm sure it is fine poetry but for a simple mind like myself (and with the language barrier on top) impossible to understand.

With the risk of misreading him and the same language barrier I understand it that he wanted to lynch me yesterday , doesn't think me a bad lynch for today but fears I'm town so much that he doesn't vote me

[Serdoa]

Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.

Pindicator

Pindicator

I can also get behind it, even putting a vote where my mouth is (Hello Rowain).

[Lewwyn]

I probably need to start a spreadsheet to even keep track of all my questions.

Also, where is Lewwyn? I really would like to hear his thoughts, even in rhymes.

Today is dark and cold and rainy
I had no class and laid in bed
physically not under weather
just take some time to clear my head.

give me a few minutes to quote and respond
there's a fair bit mired in this pond.

[Rowain]

Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.

Pindicator

Pindicator

I can also get behind it, even putting a vote where my mouth is (Hello Rowain).

I hope you understand why I'm a bit more reluctant about jumping in bed with novice

[pindicator]

Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.

Okay, what part about his second post are you unclear about novice? I know you like to hammer out minutae that you don't agree with, but this isn't me agreeing with superdeath, it's me acknowledging that he's shown his point better:

I can see how post 135 by superdeath corresponds to what others have described as "scum going for the easy mislynch on thrawn". It's also his first serious post, almost 24h in. And it's in the middle of some interesting back and forth between various players, so it's kind of odd that he'd try to redirect the discussion on thrawn.
The fact that he comes back at post 215 but posts nothing that contributes to the discussion is also a bad point.

Pressuring Serdoa for his vote leads nowhere until he can talk freely, so Superdeath

I stayed on Thrawn because of two reasons, 1: He failed to mention anything that wasnt "what should i be" or other nonsense and i wanted him to post something of substance 2: I went to bed and was at work when he showed up at the end.

I, the great warlock of Yggdrasil do not see any reason other than deception for the glorious game-maker to give anyone the ability to make Serdoa have this talking restriction. I believe it is a classic rogue trick to avoid suspicion and protect himself from being kicked out this round.


Who would be granted such an ability? While i believe it is a ruse, my best guesses would be the Monk making someone else only able to "meditate"/vote OR Rowain the barbarian, perhaps with some sort of "rage/anger blinds you/cant talk"?

If Serdoa has this posting restriction, someone doesnt want him using the scroll that easily to bring back someone from the dead to give us wisdom. That is my best guess

You think it is a ruse by Serdoa, but you’re voting Adrien for being behind it anyway?

Meant to say "would look like something Rogue-Like" As in, if you were to use a power of deception/control like a posting restriction, the rogue would be the perfect target imo. While i do doubt that Serdoa would do that to himself ( although it would be the 500 IQ play of the century ) The 2 mentioned players are the only ones where i could feasibly see having a power that fits this problem. Of the two, the Monk seems the easier fit as Meditating is rather quiet and a full no-voting power would be WAY too OP for this game. Unless this is the magical power of the Grognard?

I took this as clarifying his first post to mean that someone would do a PR like this to Serdoa specifically because people could then wonder about him faking it because he was a rogue. My first reading of Superdeath's post was like yours: that it sounded like he was saying someone did it to Serdoa and Serdoa was faking it, which made no sense. This second post clarifies Superdeath's stance.

[pindicator]

Oh, I see the lynch pindicator tomorrow train is starting early.

I was about to vote for Lewwyn myself. I can understand a disappearance into RP for day 1. But day 2 he's given nothing. And I do not like that he isn't waffling on me this game.

[Serdoa]

Today is dark and cold and rainy
I had no class and laid in bed
physically not under weather
just take some time to clear my head.

give me a few minutes to quote and respond
there's a fair bit mired in this pond.

I'm sorry to hear that Lewwyn, I hope you feel better now.