(October 28th, 2020, 02:06)novice Wrote: Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.
Pindicator
Wow okay
so its that kind of day
I could use a little more
as to why you turned on pindicator
Is simply his reaction to Superdeath
or is there something more beneath
I'm not sure I can get on board
although now it seems pindi has a new sword
and is coming after me?
I have more to see.
Since pindi voted for rowain 2 days in a row
Do you think Rowain is more town than scum now?
(October 28th, 2020, 09:47)Rowain Wrote:
(October 28th, 2020, 09:41)novice Wrote:
(October 28th, 2020, 02:06)novice Wrote: Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.
Pindicator
Thats a lynch I can get aboard with.
If you don't mind:
Why is he a better lynch than superdeath for you?
I'd also like the answer to this question
it's salient to our lessons.
Also rowain you haven't swapped
would you now that your case pindi's dropped?
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
(October 28th, 2020, 09:57)pindicator Wrote: I took this as clarifying his first post to mean that someone would do a PR like this to Serdoa specifically because people could then wonder about him faking it because he was a rogue. My first reading of Superdeath's post was like yours: that it sounded like he was saying someone did it to Serdoa and Serdoa was faking it, which made no sense. This second post clarifies Superdeath's stance.
Although that is an interpretation that is at least internally consistent, I think you had to fill in pretty large gaps in what he posted to reach that clarification. Wouldn't you want to check with Superdeath that your interpretation is correct, instead of simply thanking him for the clarification?
I don't follow what you mean at all, novice. What large gaps am I making? Are you confounding me agreeing with his point with me thanking him for clarifying the point he has made?
Honestly, I wonder if you are being intentionally obtuse here. So please help me understand your thinking.
I must have missed this post before
because now your question makes more sense
I also see that the novice was responding to Adrien more
and Adrien is the start the whole sequence.
Again I find this troublesome
because its mostly meta speculation
and an easy way to have some content
and slip into discussion.
I also note that Adrien jumped to reply
when you asked your additional by and by.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
(October 28th, 2020, 10:51)Lewwyn Wrote: Also rowain you haven't swapped
would you now that your case pindi's dropped?
If you insinuate I only vote for people voting me then both are no longer voting for me.
Last game Bob believed if he agrees with me I won't vote for him being lynched. As he learned he was mistaken.
I'm absolutely sure that (at least) one of Lewwyn, novice, pindi is scum. For me it is now the task to decide whom of you three I think the most scummy.
For now I follow their discussion as it is at lot easier for me to read tones if I'm not the target.
(October 28th, 2020, 09:58)pindicator Wrote: Oh, I see the lynch pindicator tomorrow train is starting early.
I was about to vote for Lewwyn myself. I can understand a disappearance into RP for day 1. But day 2 he's given nothing. And I do not like that he isn't waffling on me this game.
I actually have not given you as much thought
beyond your rowain suspicion and vote.
Because I think (thought?) rowain was scum
your suspicion let me, let you float.
In fact during the night this is all I wrote:
(October 27th, 2020, 11:53)Lewwyn Wrote: Pindicator I'm feeling fine
he's agreeing with me most of the time.
Feeling fine was just to say
I didn't have scum vibes
on you that day.
My comment was so very short
because i'd given less thought
to you and your comport.
I wasn't suspicious before
why should I have waffled more?
And now as well I have to say
about my activity today.
Sometimes the rhymes do get heavy
and it can be a challenge to get started
I feel much better once begun
and my hesitance has parted
Yesterday the thread was dead and nothing much had happened
I was willing to take a break and keep myself from being maddened
As I said already before I started today
I felt a bit blue and had a small delay.
But if you say with a straight face
that today I have done nothing
I think that you are lying sir
and maybe you should sing.
“The wind went mute and the trees in the forest stood still. It was time for the last tale.”
(October 28th, 2020, 09:57)pindicator Wrote: I took this as clarifying his first post to mean that someone would do a PR like this to Serdoa specifically because people could then wonder about him faking it because he was a rogue. My first reading of Superdeath's post was like yours: that it sounded like he was saying someone did it to Serdoa and Serdoa was faking it, which made no sense. This second post clarifies Superdeath's stance.
Although that is an interpretation that is at least internally consistent, I think you had to fill in pretty large gaps in what he posted to reach that clarification. Wouldn't you want to check with Superdeath that your interpretation is correct, instead of simply thanking him for the clarification?
I don't follow what you mean at all, novice. What large gaps am I making? Are you confounding me agreeing with his point with me thanking him for clarifying the point he has made?
Honestly, I wonder if you are being intentionally obtuse here. So please help me understand your thinking.
Original Superdeath post for reference:
(October 27th, 2020, 19:01)superdeath Wrote:
(October 27th, 2020, 13:27)AdrienIer Wrote: I can see how post 135 by superdeath corresponds to what others have described as "scum going for the easy mislynch on thrawn". It's also his first serious post, almost 24h in. And it's in the middle of some interesting back and forth between various players, so it's kind of odd that he'd try to redirect the discussion on thrawn.
The fact that he comes back at post 215 but posts nothing that contributes to the discussion is also a bad point.
Pressuring Serdoa for his vote leads nowhere until he can talk freely, so Superdeath
I stayed on Thrawn because of two reasons, 1: He failed to mention anything that wasnt "what should i be" or other nonsense and i wanted him to post something of substance 2: I went to bed and was at work when he showed up at the end.
I, the great warlock of Yggdrasil do not see any reason other than deception for the glorious game-maker to give anyone the ability to make Serdoa have this talking restriction. I believe it is a classic rogue trick to avoid suspicion and protect himself from being kicked out this round.
Who would be granted such an ability? While i believe it is a ruse, my best guesses would be the Monk making someone else only able to "meditate"/vote OR Rowain the barbarian, perhaps with some sort of "rage/anger blinds you/cant talk"?
If Serdoa has this posting restriction, someone doesnt want him using the scroll that easily to bring back someone from the dead to give us wisdom. That is my best guess
As I asked Superdeath:
(October 28th, 2020, 01:03)novice Wrote:
(October 27th, 2020, 19:16)superdeath Wrote:
(October 27th, 2020, 19:07)novice Wrote: You think it is a ruse by Serdoa, but you’re voting Adrien for being behind it anyway?
Meant to say "would look like something Rogue-Like" As in, if you were to use a power of deception/control like a posting restriction, the rogue would be the perfect target imo. While i do doubt that Serdoa would do that to himself ( although it would be the 500 IQ play of the century ) The 2 mentioned players are the only ones where i could feasibly see having a power that fits this problem. Of the two, the Monk seems the easier fit as Meditating is rather quiet and a full no-voting power would be WAY too OP for this game. Unless this is the magical power of the Grognard?
Where does «would look like something Rogue-Like» fit into your original post?
I mean, I still don't get it. To me it reads like:
Superdeath: Monkeys can fly
Everybody: What?
Superdeath: I meant, flies can swim.
Pindicator: Thanks for the clarification.
(October 28th, 2020, 02:06)novice Wrote: Pindicator: Hmm, yeah, I could see him as scum. (Let's lynch him tomorrow.) But seriously, he just thanked Superdeath for a clarification that was not the least bit clarifying to me, at least.
Pindicator
Thats a lynch I can get aboard with.
If you don't mind:
Why is he a better lynch than superdeath for you?
I'm not sure that he is. I'm stirring the pot. It certainly triggered discussion (or less vainly, coincided with the americans getting online.)
Why is Pindicator scum in your opinion, Rowain? Simply because one of the three people voting you yesterday had to be scum? And by the way, what's your opinion on Gazglum?
