[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[novice]

I don't see any contradiction between "not feeling it" and preferring it over the field.

[novice]

But again, why wouldn't I just lynch Gaz? We'd be left with 3 scum vs 3 villagers and a grognard. Dislike my play all you like, the fact is I still should be very likely to be town in all your eyes.

[novice]

It would make much more sense for me to lynch Gaz and have my scum buddies bus me tomorrow, if I'm so afraid of getting caught.

[pindicator]

I can now speak again. 12h restriction it is.
Guys aren't we supposed to be voting for the most likely scum ? There's obviously at least one between Superdeath Lewwyn and Serdoa. I'm not convinced on the case about Serdoa, Superdeath is an obvious choice, he isn't even trying to explain his actions or his absence at the most opportune times.

Lewwyn has a lot of volume, but seems to avoid saying much of substance. Still has a munchkin-vibe from me, but that's just a feeling.
Superdeath drew my suspicion early on for attempting to provide content without any actual reasoning. Hasn't really bothered to defend, always defering to later.
Novice was on my early list of munchkins, mainly due to how he's been stoking the fires of conflict everywhere it was possible. Skull-bash seems a likely silence-ability, and was quick to defend Superdeath earlier on.

Any of these would be an information-rich lynch in my eyes.

Regarding the grognard, it still might be a serial killer: If Superdeath was the munchkin carrying out their night kill it would explain why there was only one death. Everybody then assumed that there was no SK due to only one death, which means that they could hide their nature by refraining from killing the second night. However I fear that the Grognard is something entirely different that we haven't been able to guess.

Of these I agree with Tarkeel
But many o'erlaps they reveal
Lewwyn has gone
No posting anon
His lying too tiring I feel

With Superdeath I have a fear
Too stubborn to play could be here
He did it before
But then post'd lots more
When end of that game did draw near

Novice I'm least of these certain
Serdoa's case is cause for alert and
Nov won't pursue
A case against Lew
Is that last minute vote a subversion?

Pindicator was suspect due to low participation on the first day, but has since returned to his normal self. Mostly neutral with a slight player-lean.

If I had a nickel each time
This was uttered each game I would find
Maybe twenty-five
Cents to my hide
It's a mountain I've many times climbed

Thanks Serdoa for your posts.  I still miss an explanation for the 0.1 tirbreakpower and i still see no good reason why you are so coy about it.

For novice gazglums riddle was the follow up to this.

Scorpion and Frog

Scorpion stings friend frog. Why?

"It is my nature"

Thanks ser glum for your protection :-).

Of role powers I'd like to say
That novice and superdeath claim
In some set order
To min their cover
And hear reasons for what they ordained

[pindicator]

Sadly I must later refrain
From posting as I entertain
I'll duck in and out
While cleaning the house
And be back 'fore deadline again

[AdrienIer]

RL is starting to take its toll on me, but despite the speech restriction and a relative lack of time I've tried to post a little today. Not like Lewwyn (who posted shortly after deadline and not much after that) and Superdeath. Why the sudden disappearance ?

[Serdoa]

Have to admit, I'm not really feeling doing all my write-ups if novice is just one-lining them and Lewwyn and SD are just stopping to play. I get we have 3 non-town left, so guess whom I have done for those roles right now, but I don't see much point in doing write-ups, as they seem to be a waste of time right now. Furthermore I'm fine with a lynch on either of those 3 and with Lew and SD not playing, I don't have high hopes convincing anyone about novice. I do believe novice has a higher chance for scum than Grognard, simply looking not only at his but also at WKs posts (which at least for D1 are positive towards novice and Lewwyn, but neutral to negative towards SD). 

Anyhow, I'll see if I can find energy to make a concise post putting my thoughts together, but I doubt it will be before tomorrow, like 2-3 hours before deadline. (My wife is going on a business trip for the next 3.5 half days tomorrow and I'd rather spend time with her than you guys).

[pindicator]

I too wonder why at this mid hour
Half our thread feels so dour
Those who past led
Are now quiet instead
Is their scum game really going so sour?

[Rowain]

Lewwyn has disappeared.  It looks like he is hoping  the novice-serdoa fight lets him glide by.

Novice looks like he wants to be lynched and refuses anything that looks like work See his answer to gazglum when the paladin asked him to look into the possibility of lewwyn snuggling up to him. Or his answer to serdoa.

[Rowain]

Lewwyn