[Game Thread] WW49: Wizards and Werewolves

[Rowain]

Superdeath

[Rowain]

Scum might hit the grognard.
I'm set on it. Not blowing up doesn't change the maths, it's a potential 3v3 instead of 2v2.

If your victory condition is to be dead night 3 then godspeed, gratulation and well played

[AdrienIer]

The thing is, it's almost certain that it's one of SD or Lewwyn. I don't see a Serdoa/Novice pair, and the others are cleared (at least for being scum)

[Serdoa]

@pindi

I'm fine with Lewwyn, SD or novice. I probably would go with Lewwyn first right now, simply because he is the one that is the most not playing like he normally does.

Furthermore I see novices point about the lynch + nightkill. Basically: Jumping on the lynch could make sense for scum-novice because he knows Lew and I are around and at least one of us is not scum, if novice is, that much is clear. But then I believe a team Lew + novice or SD + novice would choose another night-kill target, not Rowain. But that is just my believe

SD would be the obvious choice if you believe he is scum, as his power is the most bad for us. But from all the possibilities I've looked at, we should still win even if he is scum and gets a scum-buddy-vote back. Or lose regardless of that. So, I guess my point is: I don't think he is off and just voting him for his power could cost us the game.

@Rowain

If one of us is scum and is lynched now, it really makes no difference. With 1 scum, the only potential for them to win is to get to a 1-1-1 or 2-1 situation. In the former it is a toss-up if the Grog votes with town or scum, nothing scum or town can influence. And in the second scenario, he has to convince town that today - with a very narrow field of potential targets - does somehow make him confirmed town over someone that should be confirmed town. 

As my great SK-theory was blown out of the water by novice, you being scum is basically impossible (caveat: Gaz is scum too, but then this lynch isn't as important as we all think). pindi is extremely unlikely, Adrien will kill himself... yeah, no, I don't see that I or novice is alive and vote against one of you for either SD or Lewwyn...

(Let me know if my logic missed some case.)

[Rowain]

The problem with SD is you can't say anything about him. I do rather lean town on him but Lewwyns silence and all makes me want to be sure there is no return of the Wizard.

[novice]

Seems like a discussion we could have had earlier, SD is not the worst lynch. I still think we should just have lynched our top suspect, though. Superdeath’s ability is only an issue if we mislynch.

[Commodore]

Deadline, resolution might take a little bit as I am having to get my very grumpy kids some lunch first

[Serdoa]

Trust me I'm mightily frustrated by that and I had to delete some choice words from ... several posts. Because in the end it is unfair by me, everyone has other occupations and this is simply not a club activity you do twice a week and you can plan around. But at the same time, I have to look how others are playing or not doing so - and people get upset when I judge them by it. But what else I'm to do? 

(I've deleted some stuff that is probably better saved for after the game. My wife is on her way now and I always get depressed when she's not here, so I probably would be much too harsh for reasons that have nothing to do with the game itself.)

You two have been so on each other throats not even a bucket of ice-water would have separated you.

No. I written now three times some things to say to that ... but I'll just don't ...

[Commodore]

Tally as of 12:00 CST 11/1/2020

4.1 votes Superdeath (AdrienIer, Rowain, Pindicator, Lewwyn)
1 votes Lewwyn ( Superdeath)
1 votes Novice (Serdoa)
1 votes Serdoa (Novice)

Look correct?

[AdrienIer]

Yes