As a French person I feel like it's my duty to explain strikes to you. - AdrienIer

Create an account  

 
RB PBEM 2 - de Krill of Fronce

Darrell has a deal for Astronomy with SL?

Er, did he actually intend to do anything with me in this game? Or was he just bullshitting? regoarrarr, you are in the clear: Darrell is much less trustworthy than you tongue

As of now, Dreylin and SL have agreed to the proxy war, but I'm reconsidering declaring on him and capturing cities on the first turn, Musketeers all the way.


Quote:21:17 me: cahtchatchat
Squareleg: ok
21:18 me: Long story short
Darrellis acting like a good old fashioned sociopath in this game
sodon't trust him
Squareleg: He has tried to be friendly with everyone
21:19 but that don't get you anywhere
me: Well, he effectively strong armed me into a game long NAP and then did the whole Steel thing with Dreylin
21:20 OS me not happy with him
*so
21:21 Squareleg: so what do you want from me? Cold war>
me: Well...
whathaveyouheardfromDreylin?
stupid spacebar
21:22 Squareleg: That he doesn't trust Darrell either
21:23 me: Well]
I've asked Dreylin to help me ina proxywar
21:24 tbh, I'd wage war myself with help from Dreylim ,and your self if you wanted, but I don;t know how people would view the gamelong NAP after Darrell screwed about with Steel?
Squareleg: Are you actually going to attack Darrell? Btw - I agree with Dreylin and you on this in that Darrell has tried to talk his way through everything signing deals he can't support
me: Who would it reflect worst on etc
Yes
21:25 I don;t care about the land
Squareleg: Dreylin and I have discussed a little on email
me: I just want Darrell either down to a shit island or eliminated from the game now
and I don;t care whatot does to my chances of winning
Squareleg: for the record: I think you were both stupid for signing a game long nap
BUT
21:26 Without knowing the details of the arrangement - I think you have case for breaking it. Darrell fears that ;-)
me: I have chat logs where Darell admits that he'd force a 4v1 if I didn't sign it...
21:27 Squareleg: brb...
me: so yeah, I feel that I'mok with a war, but then I do have a rather emotional argument that othersmight not agree with
brb myself
21:30 back
Squareleg: I know - I reckon the opinion will be pretty split.
21:31 Why did you sign the NAP? Were victory conditions in it by any chance?
me: Iagreed to it because the other coice was a 4v1
Me and Darrell were talking about Lib
21:32 and agreed to go for Steel, in principle
then a few turns later, rings me up and requestts the gamelong NAP or he won't go forSteel
Squareleg: you know - I'd have beaten you guys to lib had i got a GS instead of a 2nd GA whilst in my golden age... ;-)
21:33 stupid SoZ
me: Doubt it...youwouldhave made Steel impossible...but we could build research/wealth and split gold
I could pushabout 500 bpt
Squareleg: Yeah but darrell was on lib - not you
me: before boni
21:34 (I got Philo in 1)
Squareleg: I could bulb reaminder of edu with big overflow and nail lib 1t sooner than darrell
me: I'd have done Lib though
andtaken Astro
Squareleg: spose - had i popped a GS it would have been out of the bag
21:35 me: exactly, Iwas waiting for it
Squareleg: Ok - so by waging a proxy war against Darrell what is in it for me?
me: Would you care to join in and havesome of the land?
21:36 Squareleg: It is the other side of the world to me though...
me: Idon't have your world mapsocan't reeally comment
Squareleg: I'd be more interested in tech.
21:37 me: I'm definitely happy to tech trade with you andDreylin
for instance, if you have not yet played the turn, I know I willbeat you to Astro
21:38 Ialso have Steel, but I'munsure whatyou have lined upwith Darrell for that
Squareleg: nothing
21:39 brb - missus is being a pain...
21:41 me: np. As I've said before, I'm not really interested in Darrells' land, but someone has to have some of it. Dreylin has also said he doesn't really want any of it, so has asked that I cede him some land that I have next to him for his help. However, if you got your FP down,youcould quite easily make Darrells'gold island, and Yaz's old land productive if youwanted them
21:44 Squareleg: Sorry - back
ok - let me have a conflab with Dreylin - I wnat to be on the same page as him since we have worked closely for a while now.
21:45 me: Thought as much
fwiw, though
If there is going to be land redistribution
I'm going to have to claim the remainder of my home island
however
21:46 if I don't have to give up land I've alreadysettled, I don't mind if someone else has Darrellscore
and I wouldn't mind not gaining anything land wise
21:47 so if you and Dreylin were to join in, you'd both get a good 5, 6 cities out of it
21:49 Squareleg: ok - thanks for putting everything on the table - I appreciate your honesty. We'll spaek again soon. I have not had any reason to distrust you whereas Darrell I have - I can see myself either backing you - or not getting too involved - not backing Darrell.
me: Thank you
and again, I'm happy to trade Astro to you (and Dreylin) if you take me up on the offer.
21:50 and Steel to you

Quote:00:11 Dreylin: you around?
00:12 me: I'm here
yes
Dreylin: Cool
SL & I chatted
00:13 me: cool
Dreylin: We're willing to proxy for you
vs. Darrell
me: Awesome!
00:14 Dreylin: Details to work out and suchlike, but we're onboard
me: ok
Dreylin: (& my NAP to expire)
00:15 We still owe Darrell Astro as part of a previous trade
me: oh?
Dreylin: so SL will finish that off
me: backstabbing bastard
I owe that to him as well
well
Dreylin: heh
me: we were working ona deal, anyway
00:16 I'mhapppy to give youastro to trade to him
and SL researches something else that isn;t traded to him smile
Dreylin: hmm, well we'd have to talk about that
00:17 me: Well,the offer is there
00:18 Dreylin: OK, well SL and I plan to have another summit tomorrow to work out our negotiating position
wink
but I had a deadline
me: Would it be helpful if I made a couple of extra points?
Dreylin: yes
00:19 me: I would be interested in setting out some tech trades
And beyond that, not really interested in much
Dreylin: So basically the land is ours to divvy up?
00:20 me: Well, if you don't want anything that I already have, sure
00:21 Arguably Darrells' mainland city next to my land would be pretty crippled to either of you, but I am happy to not claim it
Dreylin: Yeah
me: If you want some of my land, then I'd have to request that I get some of Farrels land,
00:22 but that would be negoitiatedover
*Darrell
Dreylin: sure, that's what I expected
and you'd supply a bulk of the troops?
00:23 I assume we'd discuss how best to go about the attack
and who builds what, etc.
me: I can go to a proper war footing, yeah. As I said before, it is best if I mainly make boats because they will be uber powerful and Darrell can't compete with them
Even on equal tech
But I'm not really fussed
00:24 Dreylin: I'd suggest SL builds Galleons, I build land units, you build Frigates & some land
00:25 me: Works for me
00:27 fwiw
I'm working tomorrow and Tuesday
SoI'll be leaving home at 1900 GMT
Dreylin: OK, well SL and I will work something out
00:28 BTW, you want me to offer Peace/Cease Fire, or stay at war for the time being?
00:29 me: up to you. Arguably better to stick at war though
00:30 Dreylin: That was my thinking too
00:31 me: Question: Considering how Darrell has acted (and now in light of the Astro bollocks) do you think the NAP between me and him means anything at all? Would other people hold it against me if I declared on him?
Dreylin: I honestly don't know
That's probably one for the lurkers
(who won't answer)
00:32 me: Well, proxy war, real war...
Dreylin: yeah, there's that
00:35 but in the terms of community perception, maybe you have a bit more to do
00:36 me: yeah, thinking of that
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23

Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6:  PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
Reply

So...let's chronicle all of the Deal Breaking that has happened in all previous games, shall we? I want to rank them in order of nastiness, as well, in a second list.

These are the ones that I remember:

Dsp, and mhk (and then Shady messing about with the alliances afterwards) stiffing the NUTA (Ruff, Imhotep, Krill) of tech (Nationalism, Gunpowder, Chem?)

Kathlete against Byz, breaking an NAP (I think? I wasn't on the forum at that time)

Kathlete against Inca, breaking NAP and using Incas' gifted army against them.

regoarrarr convincing Alex (took over from Shady) to use TTs' (formerly Dsp) army to attack Munro, when there was an agreement to attack regoarrarr.

What else can people think of?
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23

Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6:  PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
Reply

Dantski abandoning CoW in middle of an invasion without a word to his comrades-in-arms.
Reply

That be one other. Did you ever break anydeals Jowy?
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23

Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6:  PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
Reply

Message sent to Dreylin and SL, in jest...

Quote:Something just came to me in my sleep deprived delirium...3 Englishmen (I assume...I don't know which city Dreylin is from tongue) about to go to war with an American.

Is the War of Independence an appropriate theme? We do have the Native Americans in the game...

Krill
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23

Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6:  PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
Reply

Krill Wrote:That be one other. Did you ever break anydeals Jowy?
Nope, atleast no significant ones. I *was* allied with Athlete on RBP2 but I always honored my deals and took NAP's seriously. Maybe I shouldn't have cry Good to hear there's some dirty tactics used in this one, haven't lurked in a while. Should make a good read.
Reply

Krill Wrote:Kathlete against Byz, breaking an NAP (I think? I wasn't on the forum at that time)

I don't remember there being a NAP at the time, but I could be wrong. Rego? Athlete?

And don't forget PBEM1, with the Athlete's NAP and Defensive Pact mess.

Whosit went schizo, popped some Korean workers while still under a NAP, and then thought better of it and made it up to them. So I wouldn't count that.

I don't think any deals were broken in the Defeat of Ruff in PBEM1.

Your call on what to consider the Death of France in PB3.
Reply

Cyneheard Wrote:I don't remember there being a NAP at the time, but I could be wrong. Rego? Athlete?

regoarrarr will post at some point wink


Quote:And don't forget PBEM1, with the Athlete's NAP and Defensive Pact mess.

Ah-ha, yes, perhaps RB post persistent offender smile


Quote:Whosit went schizo, popped some Korean workers while still under a NAP, and then thought better of it and made it up to them. So I wouldn't count that.

Worth remembering.


Quote:I don't think any deals were broken in the Defeat of Ruff in PBEM1

Ruff didn't die in PBEM1? Are you thinking of sooooo?


Quote:Your call on what to consider the Death of France in PB3.

That we are evil bastards, but I don't think we had an NAP? At least I never agreed to one with him.
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23

Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6:  PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
Reply

Krill Wrote:Ruff didn't die in PBEM1? Are you thinking of sooooo?

I think he's referring to the endgame, where Dreylin snuck out a diplo win while Ruff was rushing to space.
Reply

There was no NAP between Ottomans and Byzanz in PB2. But they were negotiating one when Byz put down a very offensive city. In all honesty the founding of Paris was a very dastardly act and would have deserved a NAP-stab.
There was also no NAP in place when Ottomans attacked Inca. The act itself (using former Inca-units) was (besides from very stupid)very dastardly.

To your case: Well as far I can see Darrellj didn't break any deal with you OTOH the acts you reported can be seen as acts of agression against you. If one takes a NAP seriously it has to mean more than 'I won't sent my Units against you'. As I stated on a similar matter before there are various possibilities to enact 'Aggressive Moves' and Darrellj did IMO (if the chats you reported are true) break the NAP.

One can't sign a NAP then turn around betray the one he signed a NAP with and go : ' :neenernee I betrayed you and dealed behind your back. But we have a NAP so you can't do anything about it :neenernee '
Reply



Forum Jump: