We just watch. And Judge. FFH PBEM III Lurker Thread.

[Ravus Sol]

Wow this anti-malkim alliance seems to have gone bottom up quickly and ina extreme way. 2 Fighting, 1 getting picked off and the last trying to create units as fast as possible.

[Xenoborg]

Won't the Temple of Temperance in GLT ruin the bonus from Pillar of Chains by removing all the unhappy faces?

[Selrahc]

Won't the Temple of Temperance in GLT ruin the bonus from Pillar of Chains by removing all the unhappy faces?

Temple of Temperance doesn't remove unhappy faces, it adds happy faces.

Tower of Complaceny or Unyielding Order both remove unhappy faces, so they would nullify the Pillar.

[Xenoborg]

Oops was thinking of the wrong thing, Temperance is a Notre Dame clone right?

[Selrahc]

Yes.

[Bobchillingworth]

I guess we might never know whose pirate ship that was

[Selrahc]

Well we know it was the Sheaim. Motives are less clear.

[NobleHelium]

I don't see why it would have said Sheaim in the combat log. It still doesn't add up.

[Selrahc]

Let me summarize the known facts then:

Nyktorion and Mardoc have not done the deed. We've seen in their thrads that they don't know what happened.
WarriorKnight has not faked the deed. We've seen in his thread that the ship was sunk.

That leaves Thoth and the Sheaim.
Thoth has shown no indication of even knowing about the affair, otherwise I'd just ask him a question about it.

Despite that though, he was cleared of involvement by Mist and Mardocs checking of the save in question, showing that the sunken ship was still alive on Mardocs turn, *after* Thoth had acted, and dead by the time the turn reached the Elohim.
That seems like compelling evidence to me, given that we know neither Mardoc or WK are lying.


The reason for the name "Sheaim Privateer" is less clear. I've previously said that it could well have been named that as part of coordination efforts between the Sheaim and the Ljosalfar, which started back when Irgy was still in power.

[Gaspar]

Let me summarize the known facts then:

Nyktorion and Mardoc have not done the deed. We've seen in their thrads that they don't know what happened.
WarriorKnight has not faked the deed. We've seen in his thread that the ship was sunk.

That leaves Thoth and the Sheaim.
Thoth has shown no indication of even knowing about the affair, otherwise I'd just ask him a question about it.

Despite that though, he was cleared of involvement by Mist and Mardocs checking of the save in question, showing that the sunken ship was still alive on Mardocs turn, *after* Thoth had acted, and dead by the time the turn reached the Elohim.
That seems like compelling evidence to me, given that we know neither Mardoc or WK are lying.


The reason for the name "Sheaim Privateer" is less clear. I've previously said that it could well have been named that as part of coordination efforts between the Sheaim and the Ljosalfar, which started back when Irgy was still in power.

While I'm reasonably compelled by this evidence, there's still the possibility that one of the players screwed up in figuring it out. I guess with Heisenberg's disappearance, we'll never know the answer to the more important question of what on earth he was thinking - its not like a Caravel is a particularly important strategic asset in this game.

As an aside, I do hope its a non-serious but important RL issue and not Irgy's postulation that Heisenberg saw WKs stack show up and bailed. I know how it feels to be demoralized by such an event, but to hold up the game for everyone else for 2 weeks with no explanation is pretty lame if its not something real and important.