One Night WW #2

[Rowain]

I'm looking forward to Gorerippers story now whether he sticks to the doppelgänger or to the Lewwyn-part.

IMO Bacchus is the best lynch for all.

[Bacchus]

Bacchus seems sure that everyone is evil except for him, which means he's probably evil. He's also "voting" for Ryan, which doesn't make sense to me.

I don't seem sure, my surety comes from what I know, which is: villager and werewolf are in reserve; no-one claimed robber and only gore claimed doppelganger. This means that either Robber and Doppel are in reserve, or they are in play, and their players hit evil roles. They can't both be in reserve, so at least one is in play. If one is in play and the other is in reserve, it means Tanner, Werewolf and Minion are all in play. Which means that these three, plus the robber/doppel are playing the evil game. One of them might be doing so mistakenly, but it doesn't change anything. What if one of Tanner, Werewolf and Minion are in reserve? Well, that means that both Doppel and Robber are in play, and both have had the rotten luck to hit evil roles. Which still means there are 4 playing the evil game. So, as I said, at best there are two other villagers (three of us in total), conscious of being such and thus listening; but there could well be just one, because it's possible that the last reserve card is, in fact, Hunter. Could even be Troublemaker, but at a considerable stretch.

[Goreripper]

I'm looking forward to Gorerippers story now whether he sticks to the doppelgänger or to the Lewwyn-part.

IMO Bacchus is the best lynch for all.

I stick to both. You all lie so badly it is kind of funny. Rowain for class president.

[Rowain]

I stick to both. You all lie so badly it is kind of funny. Rowain for class president.

Strange as I'm most likely the only one who has not bent the truth so far.

[Bacchus]

... and seems like no-one has much else to say.

Strange as I'm most likely the only one who has not bent the truth so far.

So, Rowain, you don't think either Cyneheard or Lewwyn is the true Troublemaker? Or even if one of them is, he is misclaiming his targets?

[Rowain]

... and seems like no-one has much else to say.

Yeah everybody silent. Surprising that neither Gore nor CH had anything to say during the past hours.

Strange as I'm most likely the only one who has not bent the truth so far.

So, Rowain, you don't think either Cyneheard or Lewwyn is the true Troublemaker? Or even if one of them is, he is misclaiming his targets?

One of them is not telling the truth about the TM for sure. More interesting that you implicitly acknowledged that you have bent the truth .

[Bacchus]

You already said that, in your opinion, I'll be the best lynch of all, so there's hardly any point in asking whether you think I have bent the truth — you clearly do You are wrong, but that's not new; the assertion that both TM claimers are bending the truth was new though, and interesting.

I don't get Ryan, he's had like two posts, and even after he thought he might be getting lynched offered no perspective of his own on what's happening. Meiz blundered about and then went quiet. Gore I think is a role-stealer, who is misclaiming his target to get called out on lying and get lynched. One of Lew/CH is lying, and CH has been lying low for a while now, but I occasionally saw him online. Sum of gut feels comes to (in order of confidence): Bacchus -- seer, before Rowain reads anything into this, Gore -- RoleStealer Tanner, Rowain -- original tanner, Meiz -- minion or the other role-stealer, Lew -- genuine TM, Cyne -- false TM (Evil, potentially ex-evil). I have no idea about Ryan and, hence, the last reserve card, but one is Hunter and the other is whatever Meiz and Cyne are not. Ryan -- wolf, Cyne -- minion, Meiz -- robber who robbed Cyne, reserve -- Hunter works, for example, as does switching Ryan-reserve cards or Cyne-Meiz cards. Come to think of it, Robber Meiz wouldn't have got Minion-Cyne's minion ability, so might have played straight minion when, in fact, there are no wolves in play, whilst Cyne's play is consistent with lone minion, so we could have the other wolf in the reserve too (with Ryan being hunter). Bottomline is that I will be choosing amongst Meiz, Rowain and Cyne, depending on what others say.

[Rowain]

We have ~3 hours and nobody talks besides us 2 Bacchus. Looks like everyone else wants to get lynched which of course movesme again to vote for you

[Bacchus]

I think the Evil's realised that one of them is no longer such, it's been pretty quiet since my first post that suggested we have both rolestealers in play and both have hit upon evil. And then evil could have gotten hit again by the TM, which only adds to confusion, just see Meiz's post about it all being too much to work out.

[Rowain]

Lynching me or Meiz is not the best move as either him or me have a good chance to be the tanner. But that not mention Lewwyn makes me wonder if Lewwyn isn't the right choice and you are no seer but minion guarding your 1 ww.