WW20: Legend of the Undercity

[Serdoa]

God, this game has certainly many roles influencing all the actions and results. But that should actually help the village if we stop for a moment to be paranoid of giving the scum any information. Because quite honestly, they do have more info by now anyway and have easily 2-3 good targets for the night.

That said, Rowain (and everyone else holding back night-actions that influenced this clusterfuck) you should know yourself best what to reveal, but I would really like that everyone who did influence this tells us what exactly he did. Because right now chances are high that we mislynch 2 (!) villagers, just because everyone keeps holding important information back.

Anyhow, for me it seems with the info we have that

Ichabod
Lewwyn

is fine.

[Molach]

I'll try to not post the usual 400 words in defense. But part of the case on me was that I was protecting scumbuddy Ichabod. So with village Icha and village flug on the block, I then decide to pursue BRick, yet another innocent, with a weak-ish case. Instead of posting flug's comments and gotten veteran player Ichabod hanged.
---
Anyway, I think mattimeo is the best lynch today, claim is at best neutral and can't find enough signs of scumhunting. And while the risk of mislynch exists, better now than at Lylo. There seems to be a landslide right now, and

Next tier is Azza, Lewwyn, Pindicator, Jkaen.
Then I lean village for Bigger, Rowain and Qgqqqq. Stubborn, repeated attacks on someone you know to be innocent, even after others back off, seems unwolfy to me. Rowain is more a gut feel from the posts. And Bigger for Gaspar attacking him day 1.
Strong village: Serdoa
And for all practical purpose village: BRick, Ichabod, Meiz.
---
However if there is a SK some of this is not valid, I expect a SK to be able to blend more and appear to be a scumhunting villager.

[Molach]

Mattimeo.

[Meiz]

Agreed with Molach's defense and other points as well.

[Qgqqqqq]

It was never my argument
Also the point of BRick is that you didn't give a case, despite very little case on him (not saying there wasn't any, just that votes on him should have more explaining then votes on icha/club, because he had not been as closely examined.
I'm just waiting for a response on mat - his play hasn been scummy, but I haven't noticed any clear tells.

Sersoa are you calling for a mass claim, or just a on of those potentially involved?

Can we get a vote count?

[Ryan]

Scum may lie about thier powers Serdoa. Also, revealing roles... Wouldn't that just give scum what they want ? Some powers shouldn't be revealed like bricks

[Qgqqqqq]

The point is that scum already have a bunch of kills that they're locked into.
Who are you most suspicious of?

[Lewwyn]

Mattimeo

I'm not sure how much I'll be on the rest of the day. It's Chinese New Years. Yesterday was busy. Today too.

[Ryan]

The point is that scum already have a bunch of kills that they're locked into.
Who are you most suspicious of?

Bigger or Brick ATM , I don't understand how both of them got blocked the same night and then the next night only bigger ? Well tbh Bigger claimed earlier AND maybe the role blocker is camping him. But why wouldn't Mattis power work if that was the case. We basically have 3 players being blocked and maybe even the if that's why no kill happened last night. This looks really confusing and someone has to be lying.

[Ryan]

Or I am not getting it.