WW20: Legend of the Undercity

[Jkaen]

Ryan,

An example of a town friendly WW power would be a ngihttime vig kill.

Last game I think being over the holidays and the ruleset being new to us may have changed peopels styles a bit.

Here for now we think we are back in a more standard game for us so can resort to our normal approach

[Ryan]

11 floors later -.- question about meta game discussion , how fo you think about powers in a game like this if they are not listed ? The previous game there was a list that helped us understand espocally since I was new . Now I feel lost when I guess.

[Jkaen]

Its normal for roles not to be listed, and a game like this Ichabod may have come up with non standard ones too. There is a link of common roles I have seen posted around before that may give you ideas of what sort of roles have been done before, but I would advise, especially as a first time player, that you ignore the meta for now

[Meiz]

I don't like Meiz's push for information on the nature of Jkaen's relationship with Ichabod. It seemed pretty clear from this post

Don't want to say too much this early but given what I know there may be a good reason for Morte following me around a bit and us protecting each other right now, so I wouldn't read too much into those aspects of his play.

that Jkaen was implying some sort of mason-type role with Ichabod. Fishing for more information about the nature of it feels very scummy to me.

I still feel flug is a better lynch, but Meiz is my second choice at this stage.

Like you said, it seemed clear what he implied, especially the "Don't want to say too much this early". The cat was out of the bag, so I don't get how my question affected things one way or another. It would be good to know if Jkaen was just guessing based on the game lore, so I asked.

[Rowain]

11 floors later -.- question about meta game discussion , how fo you think about powers in a game like this if they are not listed ? The previous game there was a list that helped us understand espocally since I was new . Now I feel lost when I guess.

Rest awhile and listen:
Don't gues. Ignore the powers. Trust that uberfish has made it balanced and trust that when he says the alignement was handed out randomly it was done exactly that way. There is no need to break your head about what powers char xyz may or may not have. Come time you will learn and you will also see that while there might be obvious connections between some powers and chars there will also be the contrary.

(for example Bigger was once a vegetarian Werewolf in one game andwould have won with town then).

[novice]

Bigger, do you ever actually try in these games? You're trying to ride coattails of zak's flimsy but at least partly justified crusade against me. I especially don't like the post where you try to claim credit for being part of starting it when all you've actually contributed is a joke vote you haven't moved and your "me too" posts. I'm very sensitive to people trying to get in on or deflect credit before we know results, especially under no pressure. So here, have some pressure.

But why would scum Bigger want credit for your lynch, unless you yourself are scum?

[Bigger]

I'll go with Azza. All things considered, I think he's a better day 1 lynch than Gaspar, based on what we've seen so far.

I think I could be convinced to switch to Azza, as well. I don't like the "my top two suspects are the two leading candidates" (meiz& flug) from him either. seems like a lazy scum comment - i.e. I want to be able to switch to either innocent, in case one of my scum buddies starts getting votes.

hmm, I'll have to think about it. Going to bed now, but I'll have time to catch up and cast a final vote 2-3 hours before deadline. Then - beer and football .

[Bigger]

I'll go with Azza. All things considered, I think he's a better day 1 lynch than Gaspar, based on what we've seen so far.

I think I could be convinced to switch to Azza, as well. I don't like the "my top two suspects are the two leading candidates" (meiz& flug) from him either. seems like a lazy scum comment - i.e. I want to be able to switch to either innocent, in case one of my scum buddies starts getting votes.

hmm, I'll have to think about it. Going to bed now, but I'll have time to catch up and cast a final vote 2-3 hours before deadline. Then - beer and football .

oh, I forgot to add - WATCH OUT for nasty scum. or something.

[Ryan]

Well everyone is nearly the same or the exact opposite . The exact opposites are the ones who were scum last game . So I either wait for powers to work or lynch someone new for me ? Doesn't seem fair or accurate . Unless I also treat the old guys as newbies and also treat them as If I would treat anyone new to me .

[zakalwe]

Good question, Novice. I also noticed that, but somehow forgot about it in between reading and writing up my comments.