Werewolf 12: Lurker Thread

[MJW (ya that one)]

Nevermind I misread bigger's post. It is a bit early but not bad enough to comment on.

[uberfish]

Commodore's probably a wolf.

[NobleHelium]

Taking bets on whether there's a vote snipe...

[Bigger]

I have to say, I'm dissappointed that I asked for critiques in the lurker thread (when i was still alive) and got none.

Now that I'm dead and comfirmed a villager, can anyone clue me into what I did that appeared scummy? I really think my voting pattern was very obvious town.

imo, my mistake was targetting Zak on my own, and not waiting for someone else to do it (Rowain, or whoever) and backing them up. Too many people are afraid of Zak, I think, hehe.

The circumstances around my mislynch really make me suspect Zak and Serdoa heavily. Not really sure about commodore (he really does strike me as - "I just don't have any idea how to play this game.") But it was him or me and I knew I wasn't wolf, so had to vote for him.

[NobleHelium]

There really aren't many lurkers.

I'm just here to write snarky updates.

[Mr. Nice Guy]

I have to say, I'm dissappointed that I asked for critiques in the lurker thread (when i was still alive) and got none.

Now that I'm dead and comfirmed a villager, can anyone clue me into what I did that appeared scummy? I really think my voting pattern was very obvious town.

imo, my mistake was targetting Zak on my own, and not waiting for someone else to do it (Rowain, or whoever) and backing them up. Too many people are afraid of Zak, I think, hehe.

The circumstances around my mislynch really make me suspect Zak and Serdoa heavily. Not really sure about commodore (he really does strike me as - "I just don't have any idea how to play this game.") But it was him or me and I knew I wasn't wolf, so had to vote for him.

Bigger, I don't know... even if I ignore the knowledge that I have from spoilers, you didn't read wolfish to me - your posts were all straightforward as cocky villager. Unfortunately, people were desperate in Day 2 to get some information out of my lynching - so they decided to look at my Day 1 votes. Whether they made any discoveries or not is to be seen - but one discovery is that the vote on you was not an attempt to clear Bigger the MNG pack-mate. Nor was my post-mortem response to you.

No offense, but your demise was very entertaining for me to read, especially knowing that we were not packmates.

This is turning out to be quite the entertaining game. Go Team White Wolf!

[Bigger]

I'm sure there is a good reason why wanting random lynch is a good thing. In the interests of not starting another spat, I shall try to refrain from calling it stupid :neenernee

Sorry Bigger, but you did keep dropping some sizable wolf tells. For next game, maybe try playing in a simpler manner with less room for misinterpretation. Even though I ended up not voting for you, I was also highly convinced of your guilt. Hope you had some fun anyway

1. Catwalk is spot on, the "lets see a random lynch" was terrible. It was clear what would happen in the rules.
2. I am going to have to get someone not still in the game to explain what wolf tells I was giving off before I play another WW. I don't see it, its very frustrating to me.

I also think my lynch was bad for the follwing reasons:
I am really starting to beleive commodore is innocent. But I think he's in over his head and will get mislynched anyway. I do beleive I could have gotten my head off the chopping block on day 3 if he had been lynched .

[NobleHelium]

I actually like the random lynch idea from Lewwyn's perspective.

[uberfish]

FWIW Bigger I thought you were village, you'll have to reread the game after wolves are revealed to see why your accusers thought you were a wolf. But also understand that being mislynched is not necessarily the fault of the victim as the town can get stuck in faulty reasoning.

I wasn't following the late action but the arguments surrounding who might have bussed MNG are rather weak when there's 2 out of 19 as opposed to 4 out of 19 potential partners for MNG.

[Bigger]

ok, well the night's sleep calmed me down. I agree w/ your comments uber. I'm dissappointed with the villagers that participated in my lynch, but not positive which are village and who are wolf, of course. Still, a good villager shares this with a good wolf - he needs to stay alive to be effective. I would rather avoid being mislynched - and force the wolves to kill me at night.

I think I'm just going to pm each person that voted me off as they get killed from the game (assuming they are village, if they are wolves I don't need to know why they voted me) so I can learned what made them think i was scum and improve for next game.