February 17th, 2011, 15:55
Posts: 939
Threads: 8
Joined: Dec 2010
Bobchillingworth Wrote:fire&ice should learn to count :neenernee
I guess that means i messed up somwhere votes roll assignment?
plz elaborate so furture GM's can learn from past mistakes 
February 17th, 2011, 16:01
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
Well, I don't approve the actions of MJW...
Modkill the baner would make the villagers very angry, but what he did is a completely against fair play.
February 17th, 2011, 16:05
Posts: 13,563
Threads: 49
Joined: Oct 2009
7 werewolves is pretty rough on the villagers, all the more impressive that they managed to get off to such a good start. The villagers do have a nice set of power roles, though. (And no fools.) Still, incredible that 7 wolves were unable to save Sandover.
I think F&I should have been more explicit with his rules and also posted the role PMs immediately. If he had been I think MJW should have been autolynched for his transgression. As it stands I guess he should be let off with a warning, even if he's acted stupidly on many levels.
EDIT: That is definitely a "you really should have known better" kind of warning though...
I have to run.
February 17th, 2011, 16:14
Posts: 7,548
Threads: 63
Joined: Dec 2005
Ichabod Wrote:Well, I don't approve the actions of MJW...
Modkill the baner would make the villagers very angry, but what he did is a completely against fair play.
Yeah and to echo novice, I (as someone who has never played this) had no idea that kind of thing was not allowed and in fact suggested it up-thread (spoiler thread).
You folks that apparently play this regularly need to take pity on those of us who never have!  I think comparing that to reading your neighbor's spoiler thread is not very accurate.
February 17th, 2011, 16:17
Bobchillingworth
Unregistered
fire&ice' Wrote:I guess that means i messed up somwhere votes roll assignment?
plz elaborate so furture GM's can learn from past mistakes
Your vote tally at the end is off because you listed three of the players twice and didn't mention uberfish.
February 17th, 2011, 16:21
Posts: 23,603
Threads: 134
Joined: Jun 2009
Death by GM on MJW, but PM another player and give them the l33t baner powerz.
Current games (All): RtR: PB80 Civ 6: PBEM23
Ended games (Selection): BTS games: PB1, PB3, PBEM2, PBEM4, PBEM5B, PBEM50. RB mod games: PB5, PB15, PB27, PB37, PB42, PB46, PB71. FFH games: PBEMVII, PBEMXII. Civ 6: PBEM22 Games ded lurked: PB18
February 17th, 2011, 16:23
Posts: 7,902
Threads: 13
Joined: Aug 2006
Krill Wrote:Death by GM on MJW, but PM another player and give them the l33t baner powerz.
That would certainly punish MJW, but I'm not sure if it would actually penalize the villagers as a team, since their baner is already exposed at this point. Reassigning the baner powers might be worth the loss of a villager (or perhaps not).
February 17th, 2011, 16:40
Posts: 939
Threads: 8
Joined: Dec 2010
as a thought since killing him seems like a bad idea we could make him a fool banner which did not exist and assign a random villager the real banner role.
February 17th, 2011, 16:57
Posts: 4,138
Threads: 54
Joined: Dec 2009
fire&ice' Wrote:as a thought since killing him seems like a bad idea we could make him a fool banner which did not exist and assign a random villager the real banner role.
I don't think that would work. You either have to leave it as it is or kill him. Surely he could just reveal his fool character as an alibi for acting in such a way? Introducing more secret roles would probably be too messy as well.
If you kill him, then transferring baner powers would probably be my favoured option, as it probably saves the game being swayed too much by the silliness of one guy.
However, if this is his first ever game then it may be worth a strongly worded warning and a lesson to all players & GMs about making things crystal clear.
"You want to take my city of Troll%ng? Go ahead and try."
February 17th, 2011, 17:30
Posts: 9,706
Threads: 69
Joined: Dec 2010
regoarrarr Wrote:You folks that apparently play this regularly need to take pity on those of us who never have! I think comparing that to reading your neighbor's spoiler thread is not very accurate.
Well, I never played a Mafia game, but it seemed obvious to me that that wasn't a fair thing to do.
Maybe I'm overreacting a bit, but for me a move like that is against the spirit of the game. But I really don't know what penalty should be imposed...
Ah, one question, fire&ice, do the villagers need to kill the villager possessed by Ilios to win or does he count as a villager for deciding the winner?
|
