Werewolf 12: Lurker Thread

[Ichabod]

Agreed. I like funny zakalwe, but it's too easy for his funny to look furry, and too easy to vote for him.

Zakalwe is also being pretty good when confronting accusations, but he's not putting forward a lot of accusations. That's very wolfish behaviour.

[uberfish]

I haven't been following that closely but,

Mardoc white, Zak black

3rd wolf faction doesn't exist

PR balance speculation is pointless

[NobleHelium]

Nah, my main point was that you'd try to balance the wolf packs so as not giving more powerful abilities to one or the other. But the high number of tracker/watcher like roles is starting to make me feel like that may not be the case.

Sure, I'd definitely say that the wolf packs are balanced against each other.

[uberfish]

Haven't really been reading in enough detail to be sure on Mardoc, but I remember him making a good case on MNG and then being reluctant to vote day 1

[Mr. Nice Guy]

Welcome, Mardoc!
Commodore, did you think Mardoc was Team White?

[Mardoc]

I have to say, I'm dissappointed that I asked for critiques in the lurker thread (when i was still alive) and got none.

Now that I'm dead and comfirmed a villager, can anyone clue me into what I did that appeared scummy? I really think my voting pattern was very obvious town.

Bigger, two things. First, it's *really* hard to critique play when you don't know someone's goals!

What seemed scummy to me? You talked too much about yourself, and not that much about your suspects. That's a scum tendency (no, not proof, obviously). And...it was Day 2, it's a crapshoot anyway, someone's got to hang but no one knows much of anything. Don't read too much into it.

[Mardoc]

I can't see why people suspected me so much... I hope I haven't just made a lot of confusion to the village with my crazy amount of posts...

Ichabod, it was partly what I said, partly your tendency to respond to criticism with a direct attack on your accuser. But mostly, it was a firm belief that you're a freakin' scary wolf, when you roll wolf. That meant the little stuff that I'd just write off if it was someone less good at this became, in my mind, the only clue I'd ever get.

Plus, I believed that only a determined attack could ever get you lynched. Still true .

[Mardoc]

I really hope Mardoc is a wolf. I'd hate to make Mardoc so angry if he's not one (if he's one, he's probably faking it a bit). Mardoc is such a nice guy that I have difficulty voting for him even if this is just a game. So for me to do it, it's because I really suspect him.

Frankly, Ichabod, you're about the only member of team Village who didn't make me angry. Well, maybe Molach and Meiz get a pass, cause they at least thought. Edit: I didn't exactly read today that carefully, there might be others. I have just now discovered how hard it is to be objective when under suspicion. But at least your suspicions were based on thinking I was too clever for my own good, not the rest of the village's belief that I was too stupid to realize I was exposing myself.

I had no idea the general opinion of me was that low . I think I'd be a pretty good wolf, certainly refrain from being that blatant if I were. But, well, I guess I'll never find out, cause I am *done* with werewolf.

Anyway, I see speculation about why I gave up. It's like this: if the village was willing to believe such a (I thought) blatant frame, then either:

1. The village is idiots
   
2. I'm an idiot
   
3. Or the village thinks I'm an idiot.
   

In none of those cases is there a chance of enjoying whatever remains of the game, so I might as well stop throwing good money after bad. Plus I did have a busy weekend, would only have been able to put 2-3 hours into the game in any event.

My speculation on wolves? I have to believe it's the smart ones, so that "The village is idiots" can be true.

[Commodore]

Welcome, Mardoc!
Commodore, did you think Mardoc was Team White?

Heh, nope, but we were perfectly cheerful to see a mislynch. Really need to railroad you guys now though.

[Rowain]

The other thing is that I would have set it later but I thought that I would be able to catch at least half the Euros with a midnight UTC deadline, but apparently not.

Ah but we have DST in effect So midnight UTC is 1AM for Greenwich and 2 AM for the CET (myself novice catwalk) and even 3AM for the Finns

I'm glad he's getting heat and being remembered. He's being a little too funny and not so helpful than normal. Maybe that's just lack of time, though.

He is extremly unhelpfull this time around.