Werewolf 12: Lurker Thread

[uberfish]

Yeah, definitely. I am not used to games where everyone has a power and mass power claims are common, so I didn't take this into account. I'm used to situations where people just say they're a vanilla villager when pressed.

Everyone having a power isn't a standard or anything, it just fit with the themes of the last 2 games I ran.

With 2 evil factions, I would probably have run 3/3/15 or 1/5/15 with simultaneous night kills (expecting some wolf on wolf action) and not tried to give everyone a power btw

And wolves getting (mostly) randomly killed off early on *cough* also helped cause things to unravel quickly.

Not random at all. Village clearly outplayed wolves on day 1.

[pling]

Not random at all. Village clearly outplayed wolves on day 1.

Given what pindicator says about my death I'd say every wolf that died was coz someone or someones decided they looked wolfy & thus should be killed. So I'd also disagree with NH here, the wolf deaths were random only in the sense that the powers/alignments were random.

[Bigger]

Cannot be lynched means cannot be lynched.

ok. now that I think about it more the white announcer really missed a golden opportunity to mislynch catwalk (or less breed some chaos by backing up tasunke's conspiracy theory). The silly "you will all be assimilated" commented was bad - he confirmed catwalk's villager status for no reason at all (since the village know's from MNG's death that the announcer only has 2 charges, and was was used with the "grey wolf" claim on day 2).

[NobleHelium]

Is it really that hard to understand that messages in spring green are GM messages?

[pindicator]

Welcome zak! I guess voting for me before novice's reveal didn't do you any good at all

[Bigger]

Is it really that hard to understand that messages in spring green are GM messages?

I just assume all reporting messages from you are announcer messages?
Now that zak is revealed as the other announcer, I'm assuming the assimilation comment was just you being glib?

welcome, Zak. You did a great job railroading me on day 2 and keeping commodore alive for another day <g>. Good job surviving so long, I would have been pushing for you every day if I was alive, hehe.


Now whose the last wolf? I still am having trouble believing Serdoa is innocent, but thats looking more likely.

[MJW (ya that one)]

Well if I have to guess who the last werewolf is I would go with Tasunke because it would look cooler if I'm right--because I guessed Tasunke near the start of the game.

I think this set up favors the village a lot. In order to make this game intersting the wolfs needed to pick up the slack. This did not happen. For example MNG went AFK while under pressure and commedore misread his role PM. So it became a cakewalk for the village.

[Bigger]

that, and I don't really think a 13-4-4 set up would have been a bad idea (wolves would have to hunt each other, increasing likelihood of a wolf lynch, as well as likelihood of a woof night kill).

[pindicator]

Well if I have to guess who the last werewolf is I would go with Tasunke because it would look cooler if I'm right--because I guessed Tasunke near the start of the game.

I think this set up favors the village a lot. In order to make this game intersting the wolfs needed to pick up the slack. This did not happen. For example MNG went AFK while under pressure and commedore misread his role PM. So it became a cakewalk for the village.

Having two noobs on one pack didn't help either

[Bigger]

Having two noobs on one pack didn't help either

bah. you didn't play that bad, and you had a very good veteran wolf on your team.