WW20: Legend of the Undercity

[Ryan]

Matti*** not Maria lol. 5th time I write his name wrong hel kill me.....

Then I am sorry but this is how Mafia was played day 1 in sc2. X min days , x min nights. Random lynch day 1 , no lynch unless powers reveal and you have to guess based on powers who is scum. If this is so blatantly different again I'm sorry but we are going off point.

[Qgqqqqq]

What on earth are you talking about?
Yeah it only comes unto effect if his target uses his ability - why does it follow that Lewwyn used an ability?
Lewwyn clearly DIDN'T use a ability, as icha would have felt it - oh wait Matt's power delays actions for the whole game
There is nothing to indicate that ichas target used a ability except that icha should feel the effects - seriously, wait for icha to tell you it (I'm 95% sure I'm right).

[Ryan]

Read Serdoas post. I am not explaining it again for the 100th time to a guy who just wants to refuse to read. God you are slow.

[Ryan]

I don't like vote jumping Azza.

[Serdoa]

The fact that you are ignoring everything we provided and still think Ichabod gives him a town lean ? We provided an explanation for the dead roles and how it reached to this. I feel that this is stronger than him floating on Jkean while throwing accusations else where. Q why don't you tell me what is this wrong with this argument and makes sense.

How do you explain the two kills last night, while Ichabod states he taunted Lewwyn. Like I posted in http://realmsbeyond.net/forums/showthrea...#pid340930

So the only way Lewwyn is the sk is that uber made a rule that delayed action is not affected by Ichabod's taunt. How likely do you think that is?

Q, again, that is wrong (though I think we crossposted).

Lewwyn kills on N2, Matt delays it to N3.
Ichabod taunts Lewwyn N3 but Lewwyn doesn't do anything N3 because that would give him away anyhow.

That would be one explanation if Lewwyns N2 action happens before all else. The other explanation:

Lewwyn kills novice on N2, Matt delays it but as novice dies anyway nothing happens anymore.
Ichabod taunts Lewwyn N3 but Rowain protects Ichabod and with that Ichabod still lives while Rowain is dead.

There is nothing in there that is unbelievable or impossible. As I said, you might not agree, but please don't make it sound as if we would try to bend the rules in all directions for it to work. It works within the rules as we know it and there is nothing being impossible nor is anything contradicting itself either. It all works within the context we have.

As for Lewwyn itself: I agree that we disagree on his play I just expect a different play from him.

[Qgqqqqq]

Ah thanks for explaining serdoa (tbh I think Ryan is hurting your case - he speaks if a superpowered Matt that combines with the rowain kill), your point on a no kill makes good sense.
I do disagree however - but again this is on a different take on Lewwyn s play, I see it as scum hunting day2 and then ceasing because of RL stuff.

[Qgqqqqq]

We did xpost (though I think you posted the wrong quote, cou you post again with the right one (spoiled of course) so I can read easier?
As I said, you and Ryan are using different meta (yours is plausible, I disagree strongly with Ryan's)

[Serdoa]

One point besides Lewwyn:

I don't think Azza is scum. I will have to review him in detail, but as of now, I feel he is posting more and adding especially more points than he did in any game before. Maybe he did that to not get caught as scum, but I'd rather believe that he understood that as villager he just have to add a little bit more of his (good) insights in order not to get lynched.

I also don't believe that pindicator is scum. Seems to interested in discussing, despite his post restriction.

I believe Meiz is village, though that does need Lewwyn to be SK. His play is still not what I would expect, I don't understand why. Somehow we seem to disagree quite often this game.

[Azza]

I don't like vote jumping Azza.

I'm confused. Why don't you want me to move my vote to the candidate you're pushing for lynch?

[Ryan]

I don't like vote jumping Azza.

I'm confused. Why don't you want me to move my vote to the candidate you're pushing for lynch?

You were attacking molach a few mins ago..... And just changed out of the blue.




@ Q Serdoas case.... Il go kill a cat ....