WW26 Lurker Thread

[Bert The Bard]

To my knowledge there are no bastard roles.

Good to hear. A scum redirector then, or a scum/third party ploy.

It's too bad we might have another three days with little action.

Just to keep the lively discussion in here going I'll throw in another identity guess, this one's just a shot from the hip though.

Half-Nose Harry:

Pindicator

[Bert The Bard]

This is stupid. I am not a fool. It does not say fool in my PM. It says seer

That's what a fool is. A fool thinks he's a seer, but he doesn't get accurate results. In your case, if you are a fool, it would specifically be completely random results. That's why it's a bastard role to put in the game, the game master lies to the player. It's probably a bit more reasonable if there is a real seer as well to balance things out, but if we had one, he would have spoken out before we lynched Kate. If you really are a villager and the fool, don't worry man, you played everything exactly as you should have. It's not your fault we got screwed.

Muriel, if Will is a friendly neighbor like you presume, how does that make him "not exactly confirmed"?

Because there is the chance that he is a scum-aligned friendly neighbor. I don't know if there is some other term for the scum version. We had a seer, a double voter and a few very strong villager lean players already out in the open, it's not like hiding his role would help the village at this point since the wolves have so many other juicy targets. If he was a villager friendly neighbor, he should have revealed it when I asked, since there is no reason to hide it, and every reason to reveal it.

Well is the GM a bastard, or isn't he?

[NobleHelium]

What is a "friendly" neighbor, exactly?

[Bert The Bard]

What is a "friendly" neighbor, exactly?

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?titl...y_Neighbor

[Kate The Waif]

I'm thinking that there is about a 50% chance that Saul is a wolf, maybe a little less, but the precedent cannot be set that giving a seer result that turns out to be false is not an automatic lynch.

[Bert The Bard]

I'm thinking that there is about a 50% chance that Saul is a wolf, maybe a little less, but the precedent cannot be set that giving a seer result that turns out to be false is not an automatic lynch.

I guess it shouldn't be automatic, but it certainly warrants a lynch.

I think Muriel is a (newcomer) villager with a bad case of "the game revolves around me" syndrome. The double voter claim was already curious, with Muriel's insistence that her claim was the be-all and end-all of the village, as if scum didn't have other nightkill priorities and couldn't simply mislynch Muriel.

[Bert The Bard]

But it worked out! Because last night I scanned Kate the Waif and she is a wolf. Too bad I won't get to scan Know-Nothing, but I think saving one person from being shot and finding a wolf is worth it.

Somebody should ask Saul how his result was phrased.

[Ichabod]

Any guesses on who's Muriel?

[Lady Elizabeth]

I thought Muriel was Gaspar due to her anger. But I'm wrong.
Before I'll do anything I'll spoil my secret identity...

MJW It's really not a secret though

[Bert The Bard]

Any guesses on who's Muriel?

Well, it's an american who seems to have lurked some games and who is probably an active forum member outside of WW. I think it's her first WW game on this site.

It could be someone like Merovech or Nicolae Carpathiae or Boldly Going Nowhere, for example. Out of those I think Nick is most likely.