One Night WW #2

[Meiz]

I think looking reserve is clearly best. Seer scan cannot be trusted due to role swaps. Lone wolf can look at one card and use it as fake claim so seer can find out lone wolf with little bit of luck. Plus the chance tl identify fake claims.

[BRickAstley]

Oh, and the moment when Brick revealed that I had looked "werewolf" from the reserve . Gee, thanks for that info!

Well, when one is in the reserve, it is possible.

Look at it this way: You could have looked at the "Villager", which would have screwed you over when Bacchus had ALSO seen the villager in the reserve if you had tried to hard claim that.

[Bacchus]

Yeah, that was my thinking, plus actually knowing how many evils there are in the game. The scenario were both wolves and the minion are in the reserve sounds a bit of a nightmare.

[Rowain]

Well Bacchus you should have looked at the TM-card instead of the boring villager one => it is clearly your fault

[Bacchus]

I know, I suck!

[BRickAstley]

just actually read everything in the last day of play, that was a really nice gob Cyne, congrats.

I'll be ready to play in another game when/if others are up for one.

[zakalwe]

From a quick skim, I don't understand why nobody voted for Meiz. His story clearly didn't check out, and his silence at the end was scummy. Disclaimer: VERY quick skim.

[Meiz]

Scummy play might indicate minion / tanner as well, which loses the game for villagers. And Rowain claimed tanner while cyneheard claimed he swapped me an Rowain

[Bacchus]

Zak, it was clear that Gore, Meiz and at least one of Lew and Cyneheard were on the evil team, but it was a tough call figuring out who is the sole wolf amongst them. I was up for voting Meiz, but for Rowain it was a bad deal, as either Lew has switched them (and then Rowain shouldn't vote Meiz), or he hasn't (and then Rowain again shouldn't vote Meiz and assist in a probable lynch). We probably could have coordinated a vote against Meiz with Ryan, as I had no confidence in the Cyne vote especially after Lew pushed for it, but Ryan was never online and generally didn't post. When the village has just two players of seven that are sure of their villageness, and out of those two one doesn't participate in discussion... errrr

[zakalwe]

Scummy play might indicate minion / tanner as well, which loses the game for villagers. And Rowain claimed tanner while cyneheard claimed he swapped me an Rowain

That depends on how you define "scummy play". I didn't get the impression that you wanted to be lynched.

I see your point about town's limited voting power, Bacchus.