WW38: The Story of the Stories

[Krill]

That fits with my second ability.

[Ichabod]

Can someone post a vote tally?

[pindicator]

Novice, that's awful reasoning.

My role is called Friends of All Traits - like a jack of all traits but every ability is tied to a character from the books. They're all one-offs. (Eeyore: Of course they're one off. Why would anyone want to stick around? )

Last night I used Pooh Bear to protect Ichabod since I thought he seemed like the most likely target, with how he pushed Gazglum early and then came back for the late wagon. Plus IMO he's made some of the best arguments of everyone. Well, most of his arguments... I did not kill or attempt to kill anyone last night.

I asked Brick if I still have a Pooh charge and he says I still do. So I guess I was jailed.

[pindicator]

Damn. All this time I was thinking I had stopped the night kill

[AdrienIer]

Ok that pretty much confirms it (at least the roles, alignements are a different matter).

[zakalwe]

All traits or all trades
That is my question

[Bobchillingworth]

So the claimed order of operations for last night was:


Krill tried to jail Lewwyn, but Adrien switched night actions targeting Lewwyn to hit Pindicator instead, and Pindicator tried to use up a one-time doctor ability on Ichabod but was jailed, so it didn't go through. Oh, and Fenn tried to scan Krill's role but got no result due to some sort of passive ability on Krill's end.


That all sounds... very convenient. It's possible, I guess, but I don't buy it.


Pindicator. Why were you using a one-shot doctor ability on N1? Why use it Ichabod instead of someone like Fenn?


My theory is that Pindicator tried to make a kill for the scum but got blocked. Jack-of-all-trades is a fairly safe scum claim- being only a one-shot doctor means you don't catch much heat for consistently failing to protect anyone (and actually can be faked by intentionally forgoing a night kill), and if you get caught murdering someone you can just claim you were using your vig ability. Pin doesn't seem like a particularly good scum target for N1 either, as an explanation for the lack of a kill.

[AdrienIer]

No Lewwyn was the scum target N1, but my ability redirected the kill to Pindicator

[Bobchillingworth]

Ah. Right, okay.


Lewwyn was def. more likely to have been attacked than Pin. But I still don't get why anyone would try to use a one-shot doctor ability on N1.

[pindicator]

Why would I use it on Fenn??? Did he claim seer day 1 and I missed that?

I have other abilities too; I can only use one each night. And to me Ichabod was a voice I wanted around the next day. The other stuff didn't seem as good a play.