(September 20th, 2015, 05:14)Gazglum Wrote:Note that NOvice's powers are almost entirely defensive. He is a one man Great Wall of China. That makes him an excellent target for a mislynch.(September 20th, 2015, 04:47)Rowain Wrote: No there is no misunderstanding. You are attacking me because you think I should vote Serdoa. Why do you push me to vote Serdoa if you don't think he is scum?
I push you for consistency. Your play:
- joke vote Novice
- accuse Serdoa of bad faith and setting you up, implying that you think he is the scummiest player
- but say you're really voting NOvice seriously now, though you haven't engaged with Novice at all
It may all be very consistent in your mind, it just doesn't make much sense from outside. You are harping on Serdoa specifically, avoiding the point that your play is inconsistent in general.
I agree I have made mistakes in the past with you, so I would be happy to hear from anybody else on this.
As for Novice, both you and Adrien are voting for him, without giving very clear reasons, so I am inclined to believe him innocent. He also volunteered his powers, pairing them in a way that apparently matches with Serdoa's. So, I am inclined to believe Novice's power claim.
Still, Perhaps he could be scum with the same powers as us? Maybe. Though you yourself have said you have different powers, so it would seem at least possible that the Earth Firsters do as well. Then if you look at Novice's power's specifically:
Hackproof: This sub-routine is activated at night and reinforces the security guarding access to the users pod, making it impossible for Earth First Liberationists members to kill them that night.
That makes specific reference to a self-protection against Earth First Liberationists.
So, Rowain, you are arguing that Novice lied about his powers, volunteering them right at the beginning before scum know much about the setup. And he picked ones that seemed very towny, which a scum might do, but he somehow managed to correctly pick pairings that match what other people apparently have?
This doesn't seem likely.
If anybody has Hackproof or Anchored NOT paired, they should probably speak up. Otherwise, I think we would be crazy to kill Novice today. Do you agree, Rowain? It's hard to know what you think about Novice, because you are happy to vote for him without giving him an opportunity to respond to any specific points.
I think that we should consider forcing Rowain to claim his powers, at the very least.
I dunno bout yall, but I found that shit funny. (Bolded emphasis mine)
